Halachot and Customs

I gave my father a sum of money and he returned more than I gave him; is there an issue of ribit?

AA

Question

Hello Rabbi,

I gave my father a certain amount of money, and he returned to me more than I gave him. I wanted to give him back the extra, but he said that I should keep the extra.
Is this a loan with interest? And do I have to keep the extra money with me?

Thank you very much
 

Answer

Hello,

Even in such a case, where you did not agree in advance that he would return more than the amount of the loan itself, there is a rabbinic prohibition of ribit, and as the Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh Deah (siman 160, seif 4) writes, even if the borrower gives him more of his own accord at the time of repayment, without having stipulated with him and without saying that he is giving him more because of interest, it is forbidden.

Therefore, if you want to act in a way that fulfills your obligation before Heaven, you should return the extra to him (there, siman 161, seif 2), unless he knows, or you inform him, that there is a rabbinic prohibition of ribit involved, and he nevertheless waives the extra for you; then you are exempt from returning the extra to him (see there, siman 160, seif 5). However, lechatchilah it is forbidden to do this, and one must be careful about this from now on.

With blessing,

Hillel Meirs


Tags:moneyHalacha

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube