Halachot and Customs

Catfish

AA

Question

A catfish has fins and no scales. 

Is there no assurance in the Torah that a fish that has fins has scales?

Answer

Greetings and blessings,

Exactly the opposite:

"Whatever has scales has fins, and there are those that have fins and do not have scales." (Chullin 66b).

That is, what was assured is that every fish that has scales also has fins. Indeed, to this very day not a single fish has been found on earth that has scales without fins.

By contrast, there are many fish that have fins without scales, such as the catfish, eels, and even sharks - they are fish with fins, but completely smooth.

The halacha states that if a person finds in the market a piece of fish with scales on it, it is permitted to eat it without any further check, because it certainly also has fins. However, if he saw fins, he should not eat the fish before he has also seen scales.

With blessings,

Daniel Balas


Tags:catfishfins and scales

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube