Fish, the Secret of What Is Permitted Without Slaughter
Question
Honored rabbi, kosher animals must be slaughtered according to law. My question is:
1. Why do fish not require slaughter according to law?
And we eat them after they are caught in a net.
Do fish not suffer from the suffering of living creatures?
With great respect,
Chovav Gavriel
Answer
Greetings and blessings
The ruling that fish do not need slaughter in order to permit them for eating is learned from the verse in the portion of Behaalotecha, where Moses said before Hashem, "If flocks and herds were slaughtered for them, would it suffice for them? If all the fish of the sea were gathered for them, would it suffice for them?" From here we learn that flocks and herds are permitted through slaughter, whereas fish are permitted by being gathered from the sea, although fish may not be eaten while they are still alive, as explained in Shulchan Aruch.
The reason for this, as explained in the books of the Kabbalists, is that all the mitzvot that prepare meat for eating—slaughter, checking for defects, salting, removing forbidden fat, removing the sciatic nerve, and the like—all serve to refine and bring the food closer to holiness, so that it may be fit for a Jewish person to eat. This is not the case with fish, for fish are sweeter and more refined than meat by several degrees; therefore there is no need to rectify them through slaughter, but only by gathering them from the water are they rendered fit for eating.
It was further explained that animals and beasts were created from the dust, which is a coarse element and closer to opaque materiality; therefore, in order to prepare them for Jewish consumption, it is necessary to fulfill several mitzvot with them. Fish, however, were created from the element of water, which is a more refined material element, and therefore there is no need to rectify them through slaughter.
As for birds, which are on the level between animals and fish, our Sages derived from the verses that birds were created from both the element of water and the element of dust together. One verse says, "And Hashem formed from the ground every beast of the field and every bird of the heavens" [Genesis 2:19], indicating that they were created from the element of the earth; and another verse says [chapter 1, verse 20], "And Hashem said: Let the waters swarm with a swarming creature that has life, and let birds fly above the earth," indicating that they were created from the waters. Therefore, it is sufficient to slaughter them by means of one sign, and there is no need to slaughter both the trachea and the esophagus.
In the books of our master the Arizal, it is further explained that in every food there are souls that have been reincarnated so that the Jew may rectify them by eating them in accordance with the commandments of the Torah. Now the soul that has transgressed the word of Hashem through a negative commandment or through neglect of a positive commandment must be reincarnated, according to what has been decreed upon it, into some matter, whether its reincarnation be in the inanimate, plant, or living categories, all according to the degree of the blemish and sin. The person who eats this food and fulfills the mitzvah associated with that food raises the reincarnated soul from level to level. As for the soul reincarnated in a living creature, that is, in some animal, beast, or bird, a person who eats it is required to fulfill the mitzvah of slaughter in accordance with the laws of the Torah, and the reincarnated soul senses the pain of slaughter, for such is the punishment decreed upon it, and afterward it is elevated from living to speaking, according to the eater's intention.
And sometimes even righteous people sitting in Gan Eden still need to be reincarnated for some slight meticulousness they did not observe; these are the ones who are reincarnated in fish, which do not require the pain of slaughter, and in their case the term used is gathering, like death among the righteous, which is called gathering. This refers to matters that are only slight meticulous details and not in the category of sin, and therefore they are sometimes reincarnated for even a moment in some fish before it is caught and eaten by the person eating for the honor of Shabbat and for a meal of a mitzvah, and immediately it receives its rectification.
Thank you for your response and for the greetings of peace I requested for your family. Shabbat Shalom - Menashe Yisrael

