If someone got a tattoo, are they violating a prohibition at every moment?
Question
Hello, honored rabbi, I wanted to know whether a person who got a tattoo is punished for it only at the moment of the engraving on the flesh, or at every single moment that the tattoo is on his body? Thank you very much in advance, Yonatan.
Answer
Hello,
Although there is a complete prohibition to make a tattoo inscription on one’s flesh (see Leviticus 19:28, and Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh Deah, section 180), nevertheless one who has already made a tattoo is not violating a prohibition at every moment, and therefore is not required to remove it from his flesh. However, it is good and proper for one who is able to remove the tattoo from his flesh, so that there should not be upon him a reminder of sin.
Sources: See Minchat Chinuch (commandment 32, in Musaf Shabbat, Melachot of erasing, letter 4), who wrote that having a tattoo inscription on one’s flesh is not proper for a Jew. So it appears. Thus there is no prohibition at every moment that the tattoo is on his flesh, and nevertheless it is proper to remove it. Likewise, see Responsa Lehorot Natan, part 8 (section 72), where it was concluded that if one has already made a tattoo inscription, there is no prohibition in maintaining it and no obligation to erase it, but if he wishes to remove it from his flesh he may do so, and there is no issue of wounding oneself if he does not feel pain in the flesh. And if he does it in a painful manner in order to atone for the sin of making a tattoo, that is also permitted. See also Responsa Ravvot Ephraim, part 8 (section 306), which likewise wrote that the prohibition of tattooing appears to be only the prohibition of writing a tattoo inscription, but if it has already been written there is no prohibition in keeping it; however, it is better to remove it because it looks ridiculous, and they will say that he committed a transgression and will sedate him and remove it, and he will not feel the pain and will not be wounding himself. And he again cast doubt on whether perhaps there is a rabbinic prohibition if it is on his body. However, he brought no support for this.
Also, HaRav Yitzchak Zilberstein, may he live long, in the book Chashukei Chemed (Pesachim, page 427), was asked about a Jew who returned in repentance and is unsure whether he must remove the tattoo inscription, and whether he must undergo surgery for that purpose, since even if he undergoes the surgery he will not thereby undo the prohibition retroactively, and what is done cannot be reversed. Therefore, there is reason to wonder whether it is permitted for a person to wound his body in order to remove the tattoo when in any case he will not thereby repair the prohibition, and we do not find that this is a continuing transgression. He presented this question to Rabbi Elyashiv, of blessed memory, and he answered him: removing the tattoo inscription is the proper course, to lessen impurity, and it is permitted to wound the body for this, because the prohibition against wounding is when one degrades a body that is a gift from Hashem and does not belong to us, but when one wounds in order to remove an abomination, it is permitted. He then cited from his brother-in-law, HaRav Ovadia Auerbach, may he live long, who said that proof for this ruling may be brought from the words of the above Minchat Chinuch.
Similarly, Responsa Shevet HaKehati, part 5 (section 154), wrote that, insofar as possible, it seems that a tattoo inscription should be removed from one’s body because of appearance concerns. He cited that HaRav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, of blessed memory, was asked about this two weeks before his passing, and he answered that he had not found among the halachic authorities that one is violating a prohibition at every moment, and therefore there is no halachic obligation to remove it. See also there (section 276, letter b), where he referred to the words of the above Minchat Chinuch.
See further in the book Maayan Omer, part 7 (chapter 3, section 4), where it was written that several times penitents asked HaRav Ovadia Yosef, of blessed memory, whether they were required to remove the tattoos on their bodies, and the rabbi, of blessed memory, said that they were not required to remove them. He added that he says this because the matter involves very severe pain. It is clear from this that, in his view as well, it is very proper to remove the tattoo inscription from one’s body (and the reason is that he did not concern himself with the prohibition of wounding one’s body, according to what he wrote in Responsa Yabia Omer, part 8, Choshen Mishpat section 12, letter 1, that only in a degrading manner is it forbidden for a person to wound his body. Otherwise, it is permitted). Only because it involves pain did he maintain that there is no obligation to remove it.
Likewise, see the book Maalot Rivka on the Torah (page 252), where he asked HaRav Chaim Kanievsky, may he live long, about a penitent who in the past had tattooed on his body a tattoo of a cross, may the Merciful One protect us, whether he should make an effort to remove it (and he noted that this involves substantial expense and pain), and whether there is a difference depending on the location of the tattoo inscription (for example, if it is in a visible place such as his hand, or if it was made in a hidden place), and he answered: he is not obligated; nevertheless, if he has a reason, he may do so, and this is not considered wounding himself. This is consistent with his view, as he wrote in the treatise Petshagen HaKhetav (section 3, printed within the book Sichat HaSadeh), that the Torah does not desire that a tattoo inscription be engraved on the flesh, but rather the Torah's intent is to prohibit the act itself and not the end result.
Regarding removing tattoos that the Nazis, may their names be erased, made on the arms of Jews (and here, of course, there is no issue of a reminder of sin, since it was done under complete coercion), in Responsa Mimmaamakim, part 4 (question 22), he answered a woman on whom the Nazis, may their names be erased, had engraved a number on her body, that she should not erase that number, because בכך she gives a hand to the accursed Nazi criminals and helps them make forgotten the horrific and dreadful deeds they did to the people of Israel. This also strengthens those haters who brazenly deny everything, as though we Jews are merely bringing accusations against them and seeking excuses against them. Rather, on the contrary, she should bear this mark with pride and honor. However, in the journal HaMaor (Adar I 5725, pages 3-5), a response to his words was published. See also Responsa Shevet HaKehati, part 5 (section 154), where he wrote that he heard that intentionally Holocaust survivors do not remove the marks tattooed on their flesh, in order to show the Heavenly Court what the Germans, may their names be erased, did to them, and this will serve as an advocate for them on the Day of Judgment.
See further in Responsa Nezer Kohen, part 2 (section 23), which expands on all the above.
With blessings,
Hillel Meirs

