Is it permitted to tell bad and difficult rumors?
Question
Greetings and blessings,
Is it permitted according to halacha to tell bad and difficult rumors?
(Some people say one needs to stay informed about the situation; one cannot be disconnected.)
I know that "good news makes the bones healthy," so what about bad news....
Thank you in advance..
Answer
Greetings,
It is not right to tell bad rumors directly, such as the passing of a person to his eternal rest, as explained in Tractate Pesachim (folio 3b, Rav Kahana became ill, etc.) and in Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh Deah (siman 302, seif 12), regarding which it is stated (Proverbs 10:18), "One who spreads slander is a fool."
Accordingly, it was brought in the name of our teacher the Gra, may his merit protect us, amen, in the book Amrei Noam (folio 54a), that the text of the Mishnah there should be read as follows: And for good tidings one says, Blessed is He who is good and does good; and for bad rumors one says, Blessed is the True Judge - because it is a mitzvah to announce good news, but there is no mitzvah to announce bad news, for one who spreads slander is a fool; therefore it is fitting to say bad rumors, meaning, that it is heard by him on its own. The Tiferet Yisrael there likewise wrote this (chapter 9, note 13).
[According to this, one can understand the wording of the verse in Proverbs 15:30, "good news" makes the bones healthy, whereas apparently it should have said "tidings" or "news" make the bones healthy. Also, in the blessing of the new month we say, "for good tidings and for good news." It seems that there are good tidings that should not be announced directly. It is possible to explain this according to what is known, that even with good tidings, sometimes because of overwhelming joy over something unexpected, a person may be endangered, and then it should not be told to him directly, אלא rather by allusion, until he understands on his own. See Ramban on Genesis 45:26, Alsheich, and Or HaChaim there. And in Sefer Shema Tefilati, page 280, it is brought in the name of Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky, of blessed memory, regarding the repetition in the blessing of the new month, that "tidings" means what concerns us]
However, when there are injured persons, certainly one must tell others, so that they will pray for them that they merit complete healing from Heaven, in the manner stated in Tractate Shabbat (folio 67a) that the distress should be made known to the public so that the public may seek mercy. Likewise, it is said in Tractate Yoma (folio 75a) regarding the verse (Proverbs 12:25), "Anxiety in a man's heart, let him suppress it," that there are those who explain that the meaning is that he should relate it to others. And in Mesorat HaShas there, note 2, it cites the Aruch (entry shach v) that the purpose is so that they will seek mercy for him.
May the Merciful One guard the breaches of His people Israel and comfort them with the building of Jerusalem במהרה in our days, amen, may it be His will!
Good tidings, salvations, and comforts!
Hillel Meirs

