Hugging and Touching During Niddah Days

AA

Question

I read here a question from a haredi couple who are unable to keep the laws of niddah. Baruch Hashem, we have merited that we do succeed in not coming to sexual relations, but we do not keep fully apart. That is, we hug and hold hands. Is that all right, since the matter is sexual relations themselves, and also wasted seed, right?

Answer

Peace and blessing

You are fortunate that you are careful not to come to the severe prohibition of niddah, but I am very saddened to hear that you are not careful about the distancing that our Sages, of blessed memory, commanded to observe during these days. These separations are intended to improve the marital relationship over the long term, something you do not achieve when there is no physical separation during the week or two of niddah. This time is meant only for emotional and spiritual connection, and not for physical contact at all. For the benefit of those who are interested, I am copying here the main laws of separation that were established for these days until immersion in the mikvah. Kitzur Shulchan Aruch, section 153, paragraph 1: Any woman from whose womb a drop of blood has been expelled, even the slightest amount, is obligated. It may happen in any way whatsoever, whether naturally, as is the way women see blood at fixed times, or not at her appointed time.

And even if some compelling circumstance occurred as a result of which blood emerged from her womb, she is nevertheless a niddah until she counts seven clean days and immerses properly. And anyone who has intercourse with her in her impurity is liable to karet, and so is she liable to karet, and for touching her in an affectionate manner they are liable to lashes. Paragraph 4: It is written, And to a woman in the impurity of her niddah you shall not come near. From the fact that it is written you shall not come near, we derive that all forms of approach are forbidden: one may not joke or behave familiarly with her, even in matters that lead to transgression. However, it is permitted to be secluded with her, since he has already had relations with her and also she will be permitted to him after she immerses, his urge will not intensify, and we are not concerned that he will come to have relations with her in a forbidden manner. Paragraph 5: He may not touch her even with his little finger, and he may not pass anything from his hand to hers, even something long, nor may he receive anything from her; likewise, throwing from his hand to hers or from her hand to his is forbidden. Paragraph 6: He may not eat with her at the same table unless there is some change, meaning that there should be some object separating his bowl from her bowl.

An object that is not normally placed there at another time, or she should change its place. And if their practice is that when she is pure they eat from one bowl, and now each one eats from a separate bowl, that is sufficient. Paragraph 7: He should not drink from what remains in the cup from which she drank, and if another person intervened between them, or it was poured into another cup, it is permitted. And if she drank and he does not know and wishes to drink from this cup, she is not required to tell him that she drank from it (but if he knew that she drank, only he did not know that she was a niddah, I wrote in my book Lechem uShmella that it seems she must tell him). She may drink from what remains in his cup, and some say that just as it is forbidden to drink from what remains in her cup, so too it is forbidden to eat from what remains of her food.

Paragraph 8: He may not sleep with her in one bed, even if the bed is not designated for her, and even if each is fully clothed and they are not touching one another, and even if each has his or her own mattress. And even if they are lying in two beds and the beds are touching one another, it is forbidden; and if they are lying on the floor, they should not lie face to face unless there is a considerable distance between them. The same applies if they are sleeping in two beds placed close to one another lengthwise, for sometimes they are face to face even though there is a space between the beds, and this should be prohibited unless there is a considerable distance between them. It is forbidden for him to recline even on the bed designated for her, even not in her presence, and she is forbidden to sleep on the bed designated for him, but it is not necessary to be stringent regarding sitting on it. Paragraph 9: They are forbidden to sit on a long bench that rocks, unless another person is between them. They should not travel together in one wagon or one boat if they are traveling merely for leisure, such as to gardens and orchards and the like. But if they are traveling from city to city for business, it is permitted even if they are alone, provided that they sit in a way that they do not touch one another.

Paragraph 10: He should not look at any part of her body where it is customary to cover it, but in exposed places he may look even though he derives pleasure from it. He may not smell perfumes that are מיוחדות to her, and he may not listen to her singing voice. Paragraph 11: It is proper that she set aside garments for the days of her niddah, so that they will both always remember that she is a niddah. And only with difficulty did they permit her to apply kohl, powder, and adorn herself in colorful garments during the days of her niddah, and only so that she would not become repulsive to her husband. Paragraph 12: She may not pour him a cup of wine in his presence, or bring it to him and place it before him on the table, and she may not make up his bed in his presence; but not in his presence, all is permitted, even though he knows that she did it. And she is forbidden to pour water for him to wash his face, hands, and feet, even cold water. Paragraph 13: Just as she is forbidden to pour him a cup, so he is forbidden to pour her one. Not only that, but even sending her a cup of wine that is set aside for her, even if it is a cup used for blessing, is forbidden.

Paragraph 14: If he is ill and there is no one to attend to him other than her, she is permitted to attend to him in a way that involves no touching, only through another object, even to help him up and lay him down and support him, provided that she is especially careful regarding washing his face, hands, and feet and making up the bed in his presence. And if the woman is ill, it is forbidden for her husband to attend to her even without touching, unless in a case of great necessity when it is impossible to find anyone to care for her. And if the husband is a doctor and there is no other physician there as skilled as he is, it is permitted for him to feel her pulse, since he is not doing so in a manner of desire and affection. Paragraph 15: In all the separations mentioned, one must also be careful during the days of her cleanliness, that is, during the seven clean days, and afterward, if she delayed immersing at the proper time, they are forbidden in all the aforementioned matters until after she immerses. Up to here. Intentionally I did not bring the story told in the Talmud, tractate Shabbat (folio 13), because my way is not to strengthen observance of the Torah through intimidation and threats. Success - Menashe Yisrael


Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube