The Heart of a King Is in Hashem's Hand
Question
Hello, and greetings,
King Solomon, wisest of all men, wrote: "The heart of a king is in Hashem's hand"
(Proverbs 21:1).
That is, regarding public decisions, he has no free choice, so I learned.
But what is said regarding Pharaoh, for example?
After all, even according to Rambam, Pharaoh had free will at the beginning?
I would appreciate help in clarifying these matters.
Thank you in advance.
Answer
Hello and blessings
The heart of a king is in Hashem's hand indeed means that a king does not have complete free will, and Hashem holds it in His hand to do this or that. The reason for this is that since the king rules over the public and has almost unlimited power, Hashem does not place in his hands the ability to do whatever he wants. However, in certain cases, Hashem gives the king room for choice—not full choice to do whatever he wishes, but he has a broad sphere of choice—and כך it was with Pharaoh and others.
With blessings,
Bnayamin Shmuali

