Choosing Love: The Journey to Connection

They entered the clinic with the kind of silence I already recognized. A practiced silence. The silence of two people who can manage a home, groceries, children, pay bills, and plan vacations — yet not truly talk for months.

Three children, ten years of marriage, and something between them had dried up, hardened, becoming a sort of cold peace treaty.

"I've been coming alone for four months," Rinat began. Her eyes never left his, firm yet trembling. "And suddenly he shows up. Just like that, without coordination, without acknowledgment. Am I supposed to be impressed?" she continued.

Rafael shrugged. "I thought it would do you good. That you’d see I'm willing to try," he said.

"Really? You show up once — and that’s supposed to make up for everything?"

They both turned to me, waiting for my judgment. Who was right? Who was the "adult," who was the "victim"?

But that's exactly where I stop, because the moment I try to determine who the victim is, they both become trapped.

"You feel like he’s taken something from you," I said to her. "The years, the effort, the attention, even the simple presence of a partner sharing the space. You’re right — it really hasn’t been fair."

"And then?" Rinat whispered, "What now? Should I applaud for a crumb of presence?" she asked.

"No. You’re not supposed to applaud. But you must see what’s truly happening here," I replied.

"Meaning?" she asked.

"That he chose to come. This is not a rescue, it’s not an answer. It’s a beginning. And the real question is not whether he deserves a reward, but whether you are ready to stop being a victim," I said.

"Ready? I never wanted to, but I feel like I can’t," she replied.

"That’s the only way you can truly choose," I continued.

I sensed she was scared. Not angry. Not dismissive. Just scared.

"You talk about choice, but I don’t remember the last time I truly chose. I operate on autopilot. So many years. Get up, function, survive. Someone had to hold this house together."

"Of course. And that’s exactly the point. When we survive — we aren’t choosing. Even if we are functioning excellently."

Rafael looked at me. This time really looked. "And me?" he asked. "What about me? I haven’t felt at home here for years. She closes me off. Always checking me. Judging. No matter what I do, it’s never enough," he continued.

"Love isn’t a place where you earn justice. It’s a place where you choose again, even when you don’t receive a certificate of appreciation. A real encounter cannot happen when one is hurt and offended and the other is defensive and withdrawn because then you both sink into a dynamic where each of you is waiting for the other to change. Once the other changes, then we can open our hearts. That isn’t called choosing; that’s a deal with conditions.

"True freedom in a relationship begins when I choose to stay open even when the other is closed. When you, Rafael, choose to act without needing acknowledgment for it, and you, Rinat, choose to see Rafael as a new person even though the past still stings."

"But how do you do that?" Rinat asked.

"That can only happen if you can let go of the victim identity."

"But that’s not fair. If I choose him now, I’m erasing all those years of pain I endured alone," she said, tears in her eyes.

"You’re not erasing; you’re simply not allowing them to dictate you. The choice doesn’t erase the past; it just takes it off the stage and disconnects it from the main microphone."

"And what am I supposed to do?" Rafael asked.

"Choose! Every day, not in declarations, but in small actions. By listening, not running away, even when it still hurts."

"That’s hard," he said.

"True, because that’s real freedom. Breaking free from familiar shackles is truly hard."

They left the room as something different passed between them. You could feel that there was a quiet foundation of something new being built.

*

Rafael returned for a meeting alone the following week.

"I understand why Rinat was so angry. Even when I was present, I wasn’t really with her. Rinat was with me on condition. I waited for her to change. I really feel the change happening in me; I’m trying to choose her as she is, without waiting."

A week later, Rinat came alone.

"I felt like I was seeing for the first time the beginning of true freedom. Not victory, not reconciliation, but actually choosing."

"Exactly, because love, contrary to the way we’ve been taught, isn’t truly born from emotion, but from choice. And each choice, day after day, drives away the old walls and replaces them with something else, not opaque, more flexible and vulnerable, but at least, real."

All details have been changed to protect privacy.

Hanna Dayan [email protected]

For all columns and to get in touch, click here