"I Don't Want to Throw 20 Years of Our Relationship Away"

Noam sat in the armchair across from me with slumped shoulders, and Daniel sat beside her, his arms crossed, his gaze fixed on the floor.

"I can't live without him," Noam finally said, her voice almost shattered. "I can't see myself moving forward alone."

"I also don't see any point in leaving. We've invested so much... years, children, a home... it's not something you just throw away," Daniel said.

I looked at both of them. "I hear you both speaking from a place where everything feels fixed, as if you don't really have a choice. It feels like your fate, for better or worse."

Noam nodded. "Exactly. Like it’s a decree from above, and I just need to learn to live with it."

"It's that feeling of 'everything has already been predetermined,'" I explained. "Like a student who knows their grade is already set before taking the exam, so they don't bother studying. If I have no influence, why should I bother? But a relationship cannot thrive in a place where there is no choice. It needs the oxygen of daily choices. Not a one-time choice, but a choice made anew every day."

Daniel looked up. "But that’s difficult. I don’t understand how I can choose. On one hand, we’ve been through so much together, we’ve built a home and a family, and on the other hand, it seems like the scars and scratches never heal."

"That really is the experience of feeling a lack of choice," I replied. "It’s a cognitive trap called 'sunk cost fallacy.' Imagine you paid a lot of money for a performance, but after twenty minutes you’re bored. If you had gotten the ticket for free, you would get up and leave without hesitation. But you paid, so you stay—not to enjoy it—but to avoid 'wasting' it. In a relationship, the same principle applies: the emotional investment and time you’ve already put in shouldn’t keep you if the present isn’t good. Decisions should look forward, not backward."

Noam took a deep breath. "So you’re saying we need to examine if we want to choose each other now, not because of everything that was?"

"Exactly," I smiled. "When choosing from a place of freedom, there is room for movement and growth. This isn’t a choice made from fear or habit, but from a deep understanding: I can be alone, yet I choose you."

Daniel was silent, but something in his eyes softened.

"The choice is a decision made in a single moment, but to get there, you often need to go through a process that puts the key back in your hands."

Hannah Dayan [email protected]

For all columns and contact, click here