Parashat Va'etchanan
What Moses' Unanswered Prayer Teaches Us About Faith and Trust in God
A personal journey from frustration to acceptance reveals how Moses' plea to enter the Promised Land teaches that true faith begins where human understanding ends
- Rabbanit Chagit Amaev
- | Updated
(Photo: shutterstock)For many years, I carried countless questions and grievances about different events and puzzling behaviors I witnessed throughout my life. One of the most significant turning points came after several difficult years in my marriage. During a heated argument with my husband, I cried out, "You don't understand me!"
He suddenly stopped and quietly asked, "Let's assume I don't understand you. But do you... do you understand yourself?"
I was left speechless because I had no answer. His question, whether I truly understood myself, continued to echo within me.
In that moment, I was blessed with a life changing realization: I do not understand... anything. I do not truly understand myself. I cannot fully understand what another person is going through. I do not know what the person standing before me has experienced throughout life, what traumas, childhood experiences, and emotional burdens they carry within them. Therefore, I have no real way of knowing why they act as they do, no matter how troubling their behavior may appear.
The sweetness and light of this powerful insight transformed me completely, and it will remain with me for the rest of my life.
Every Challenge Carries a Purpose
Every event in a Jew's life serves as a signal, pointing to a deeper spiritual mission and an area of personal growth and rectification that we are meant to accomplish in this world. At the same time, we live in a physical world where pain and hardship feel intensely real. More often than not, they seem to prevent us from experiencing joy and flourishing.
In this week's Torah portion, a dramatic episode conveys a profound lesson for us all. Moses pleads with Hashem to allow him to enter the Promised Land:
"And I pleaded with the Lord at that time, saying: 'O Lord God, You have begun to show Your servant Your greatness and Your mighty hand, for what god is there in heaven or on earth who can perform deeds like Yours and acts of power like Yours? Please let me cross over and see the good land that is beyond the Jordan...'" (Deuteronomy 3:23-25).
How does Hashem respond?
"Enough for you! Do not continue speaking to Me about this matter."
Our Sages explain that Moses' prayer was so powerful that had he continued praying, Hashem, so to speak, would have granted his request.
One insight my husband shared with me is that if Moses had entered the Land of Israel and built the Holy Temple himself, its sanctity would have been so great that it could never have been destroyed. Yet Hashem knew that the Jewish people would one day sin. Rather than allowing His beloved children to be destroyed under the full force of Divine judgment, He chose that His wrath would be directed toward the Temple, toward wood and stone, instead.
Three Truths to Carry in Our Hearts
From this, we should carry three truths in our hearts:
Hashem is deeply moved by heartfelt prayer that rises from the depths of the soul.
We can never fully understand the Divine plan, regardless of the time or circumstance.
Genuine faith begins where our limited human understanding ends. As Rabbi Elazar Menachem Man Shach of blessed memory said, "The obligation of faith begins where human intellect comes to an end."
When we recognize that we do not truly understand everything, turn to the power of prayer, and fill our hearts with simple faith that the ultimate purpose of everything Hashem does is for our good, we can attain a spirit that is free, peaceful, and joyful.

