Halachot and Customs

Saying Amen to Kaddish During a Live Broadcast

AA

Question

In the merit of Hashem,

Hello, honor of the rabbi,

I remember that if one hears Kaddish/Kedushah during a live broadcast, one answers to the Kaddish/Kedushah. But I also remember hearing in the past that because in a live broadcast there is a delay of a few seconds, one should not answer. What is the law? Should one answer to Kaddish or Kedushah during a live broadcast even though it may be delayed?

Thank you very much

Answer

Greetings,

1. Indeed, if it is a live broadcast, and it reaches you within כדי דיבור - that is, within about a second and a half - it is possible to answer amen. However, if it does not reach you within this amount of time, one should not answer amen.

2. In a case where there is doubt whether the broadcast reaches you within כדי דיבור, one should not answer amen (see Shu"t Yabia Omer, part 1, Orach Chaim, סימן 29, letter 14, and part 9, Orach Chaim, סימן 108, letter 103).

With blessings,

Hillel Meirs


Tags:AmenKaddishBroadcasts

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube