Halachot and Customs

Why is it forbidden to eat fish without scales?

Why is it forbidden to eat fish without scales?

AA

Question

Why is it forbidden to eat fish without scales?

Hello, honored rabbi. 

I am trying to find an answer to this, but I cannot find one... I only find that it is written this way, and that is all. But I would very much like to know, please, what is the reason behind this prohibition?

Answer

Hello and blessings,
 
Scales are only an external sign, through which Hashem taught the children of Israel which fish are permitted and forbidden for consumption.
 
From a spiritual perspective, eating impure animals leaves an impression on the soul and diminishes the Jew's spiritual ability to connect to Torah and mitzvot, and to draw close to Hashem.
 
From a logical-moral perspective, we can see that the Torah permitted only the most primitive fish, which are not sophisticated. The Torah forbade most sea creatures, as well as dolphins, sharks, and whales, all of which are animals with a high level of navigational sophistication. Among the creatures of the sea, the Torah also forbids eating seals and octopuses. Eating developed sea creatures has an element of cruelty, because complex animals feel their condition more than unintelligent fish.
 
With blessings,
Daniel Balas

Tags:fins and scalesfishHalacha

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube