Halachot and Customs
Is it permitted for a woman to speak with a man
Question
Is it forbidden to speak with men at all?
How serious is it?
Answer
Greetings and blessings,
One must not engage in idle conversation with men at all. It is permitted to speak only about practical matters and when there is a need.
What need do we have for more than the words of the Mishnah Tractate Avot, chapter 1
And do not talk excessively with a woman ... from here the Sages said: whenever a man talks excessively with a woman, he brings evil upon himself, neglects words of Torah, and in the end inherits Gehinnom:
Commentary of Rabbeinu Yonah on Avot, chapter 1, mishnah 5
And do not talk excessively with a woman - for women's conversation brings a person to sinful thought and to neglect of Torah
From here the Sages said: whoever talks excessively with a woman brings evil upon himself - meaning he causes the evil inclination to overpower him, which is called evil, as they say: great is the evil inclination, for its Creator called it evil, as it is said [Genesis 8:21], for the inclination of a person's heart is evil from his youth. And this man brings evil upon himself, since he gave it a place and the opportunity to cling to his body through conversation, and he was more wanton than other people, for sometimes the inclination overpowers them, but when they themselves do nothing to cause it, and do not cause it themselves, evil will not open up before them. And he neglects words of Torah, for the thought of Torah will not stand before his eyes while his heart is turned toward the woman and not toward speaking with her, for these are two thoughts that the heart cannot bear together:
And in the end he inherits Gehinnom - for in the end he comes to sin after, in the stubbornness of his heart, he goes on and increases words on the face of it (the correct reading appears to be: with the woman; see Midrash Shmuel). He will commit sin and go down to the grave, and this is what King Solomon, peace be upon him, said [Ecclesiastes 7:26], And I find more bitter than death the woman, whose heart is snares and nets, whose hands are fetters. That is, death removes him from the world from the life of the small world. But the woman destroys the soul for ever and ever, for she is more bitter than death, she who is snares and nets: a person, once he looks at a woman, is caught in her net, which is a snare, and he cannot escape from her, for the man sees what his heart desires and does not see what will become of him in the end of days, as the poet said: a foolish dove walks in the desert, sees the trap but does not see the snare; and nets are her heart - when she desires the man in her heart, even if he does not desire her and this man's bad fortune caused her to desire him, her hands are fetters. For if she has already seized him with her hands, he is already taken in prison, and there is no remedy for him. It is good before Hashem that he escape from her, but the sinner is caught by her [Ecclesiastes 7:26] - for the righteous, Hashem guards them, and He does not arrange for them something through which they could stumble; but the sinner, who does not distance himself from evil ways and whose heart is not whole, such a matter is arranged for him.
With success,
Binyamin Shmueli

