Halachot and Customs

Is it permitted to eat a cow's udder?

Is it permitted to eat a cow's udder?

AA

Question

Is it permitted to eat a cow's udder? 

After all, there is milk there.. 

Thank you :)

Answer

Hello and blessings,

The udders are what the Gemara calls k'chal. 

Here are the laws of k'chal from the book Yalkut Yosef Yalkut Yosef, Kitzur Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah, siman 90 - Laws of k'chal 

1. The Sages forbade cooking the k'chal [the udder of an animal] together with the milk in it, whether that of a young animal that has not yet nursed, or that of an adult animal, unless one cuts it with a knife lengthwise and crosswise [that is, makes slits in it] and presses the k'chal against a wall to remove all the milk from it. Or one should cut it into small pieces. Even then, however, the custom is to be lenient and cook it only by itself, with no meat at all. But it may be cooked with water, vegetables, and other things. [Yalkut Yosef, Issur ve-Heter, volume 3, page 495] 

2. According to our custom, it is possible to cook the k'chal by itself even in a frying pan or by frying, or as a pie, and not specifically by cooking in water. This is after tearing it lengthwise and crosswise and pressing it against a wall. But according to the Rema, one may not be lenient and cook it in a frying pan. Likewise, one should be strict regarding a pie if the k'chal was not first dried out. And the Rema wrote that it was customary to permit it if it is not in a frying pan, but in a frying pan its law is like cooking. [O.H. 3, page 500] 

3. What they said, that it requires pressing against a wall to remove the milk in the k'chal [as explained above], does not specifically mean pressing against a wall; rather, it means that it must be squeezed strongly. If one tore it in several places [in the k'chal] lengthwise and crosswise across its whole surface, that is preferable to pressing it against a wall, since in such a case the milk in it comes out more than by pressing against a wall. All the more so if one cuts it into small pieces, that is even better. In any case, one should squeeze it well by hand and wash it thoroughly, because perhaps there is still milk hidden in the small cavities, and by doing so one will be free of any concern. [Yalkut Yosef, Issur ve-Heter, vol. 3, p. 501]. 

See there for additional details of the law.

With blessings,

Binyamin Shmueli



Tags:cowsHalacha

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube