Faith

Diphtheria

Diphtheria

AA

Question

Hello, honored rabbi. 

Perhaps you could answer a question that has been troubling me a little. I learned in Tractate Berachot about ascara, which begins in the intestines, and then I had a lesson at school and the topic came up following a certain story, and the teacher told us that this is a disease that does not begin in the intestines. Perhaps you could answer me

Answer

Hello and blessings,

Ascara, called today diphtheria, is a disease that attacks the throat and the respiratory tract.

The Gemara is not dealing with an explanation of the external disease known to doctors, but with the spiritual root that brought about this disease. As you can see from the wording of the Gemara (Shabbat 33b): "When our rabbis entered the vineyard in Yavneh, Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Elazar son of Rabbi Yosei, and Rabbi Shimon were there. This question was asked before them: 'Why does this illness begin in the intestines and end in the mouth?' Rabbi Yehuda son of Rabbi Ilai, head of the speakers in every place, answered and said: 'Although the kidneys give counsel, the heart understands, and the tongue cuts - the mouth completes.' Rabbi Elazar son of Rabbi Yosei answered and said: Because they eat impure things. Impure things, would you imagine? Rather: Because they eat things that are not fit. Rabbi Shimon answered and said: Because of the sin of neglecting Torah study."

In other words, this disease is connected to the mouth, and refers to evil speech and additional transgressions. And this is what our Sages sought to teach.

Regarding the external understanding of the disease in their time, it is possible that the first sign of the outbreak of the disease was constipation, and only later did inflammation of the throat break out.

With blessings,
Daniel Balas


Tags:rare diseasesfaith

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube