Halachot and Customs
Mixed bathing: what is the problem?
Question
What is the problem with bathing at a mixed beach?
If possible, please give me sources for this. I am asking for a teen girl and need proof of how serious it is.
Thank you in advance.
Answer
A detailed responsum from Maran Rabbi Ovadia Yosef shlita, Yechaveh Da'at, volume 5, siman 63.
Question: Is it permitted for a man or a woman to bathe for medical reasons in a mixed beach, where there is no separation between men and women.
Answer: First of all, we must explain that there is a very severe prohibition in mixed bathing of men and women, as our Sages said in a greater matter than this (Berakhot 61a): anyone who walks behind a woman by a river has no share in the World to Come. Rashi explained that this is because she lifts her garments and he looks at her flesh.
The Tosafot wrote that this applies to one who is accustomed to this, because he will come to immorality and end up descending to Gehenna. In the Hagahot Ya'avetz there, it is written that this is not specifically a married woman; the same applies to an unmarried woman, who arouses the evil inclination within himself and removes shame from his face. End of quote. It is well known what was said in the Jerusalem Talmud (Berakhot, chapter 1, halacha 5), that the eyes and the heart are two agents of sin: the eye sees and the heart covets, and therefore it is said, You shall not stray after your hearts and after your eyes. And in Tractate Avodah Zarah (20b), the Sages taught: And you shall guard yourself from every evil thing, that a person should not think about sin by day and come to ritual impurity by night. The Tosafot wrote that this is a complete derivation from the Torah, as is evident in Ketubot (46a).
And Maran the Beit Yosef in Even HaEzer (siman 21) cited what Rabbeinu Yonah wrote, that it is forbidden to look at an unmarried woman by way of a Scriptural teaching, as it is said: I made a covenant with my eyes; how then could I gaze upon a virgin? And with a married woman, the prohibition is from the Torah, as it is said: You shall not stray after your hearts and after your eyes. And this is the language of the Rambam (in chapter 4 of Hilchot Teshuvah, halacha 4): one who looks at forbidden relationships imagines that there is nothing in it, saying, Did I have relations with her, or come close to her? But he does not know that the sight of the eyes is a great sin, for it leads to acts of forbidden relations, as it is said: You shall not stray after your hearts and after your eyes, and it causes teshuvah to be delayed. End of quote. And our Sages already said (Yoma 74b): better is the sight of the eyes than the wandering of the soul; the sight of the eyes in a woman’s body is better than the essence of the act.
See also Bava Batra (57b): And he shuts his eyes from seeing evil. Rabbi Chiyya bar Abba said: this refers to one who does not look at women when they are washing clothes. (Rashbam explained: that is, when he walks along the riverbank and the women are accustomed to standing there with their legs exposed). The Gemara asks: what are the circumstances? If there is another route, he is wicked. (That is, if there is another way to pass through and he nevertheless takes this route, even if he closes his eyes he is wicked, for he should not have approached that place and brought himself into temptation; rather, he should have distanced himself from sin, as we hold in Chullin (44b): distance yourself from ugliness and from what resembles it. Rashbam.) The case is where there is no other route, and even so he must make an effort to control himself (to turn his eyes aside or to close his eyes). End of quote.
All the more so one who goes and bathes at a mixed beach, where the immodesty there is very great, there is no doubt that one who goes and bathes there is called wicked, for in no way is it possible not to look at the immodest women, and his sin is too great to bear. And behold, in the Gemara (Gittin 90a), the trait of an evil man is that he sees his wife going out with her head uncovered and torn on both sides and bathing with people (and he remains silent). Bathing with people, would one think so? Rather, bathing in a place where people bathe. Rashi explained: bathing with people, would one think so? If so, there are grounds to say that she is a prostitute and is forbidden to her husband, and it is an obligation to divorce her, not merely a mitzvah. The Tosafot explained: after all, even an evil person cannot tolerate this, and even the most lenient woman would not do this. End of quote.
The Maharsha wrote that one who literally bathes with people must be divorced by Torah law. So too wrote the Ran there. And it is clear that the man who bathes there is not free of sin either. Even the unmarried women who bathe there are presumed to be menstruants, and there is no distinction between unmarried and married women with regard to the prohibition of niddah, as the Rivash wrote in a responsum (siman 425). This is also ruled in the Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah (siman 183). See further in Responsa Rav Pe'alim, part 4 (Yoreh De'ah, siman 16). And concerning the women who bathe there, there is an additional prohibition, because they transgress before the blind shall you not place a stumbling block, as the Rambam wrote in his commentary to the Mishnah (Shevi'it, chapter 5, mishnah 6), that the meaning of the verse applies to one whose eyes have been shut by desire and whose evil inclination has blinded the eyes of his intellect, and it is forbidden to help him increase his blindness by distancing him from uprightness and truth. End of quote.
And it is a great mitzvah upon the rabbis of Israel to inform the people of the severity of the prohibition, to build a fence and stand in the breach, and to remove the stumbling block from Israel. For they already said (Sanhedrin 107b): the God of these hates immorality. And the leading sages of our generation have already issued warnings about this, among them the great Rabbi Shmuel Halevi Wosner shlita in Responsa Shevet Halevi, volume 3 (siman 185), and the great Rabbi Moshe Feinstein shlita in Responsa Igrot Moshe (Even HaEzer, siman 56), and the great Rabbi Moshe Stern shlita in Responsa Be'er Moshe, volume 4 (siman 147). Likewise, in the book Taharat Yom Tov, volume 8 (page 164 and onward), several great authorities at length in their responsa explained the severity of the prohibition of mixed bathing in the sea or in swimming pools. End of quote.
Therefore, even when one does so for medical reasons, there is no room to permit it, particularly since he can find a place where there is no intermingling with women, so that there will be no mixture there. And the great Rabbi Chaim Palaggi already wrote in the book Mo'ed Lechol Chai (siman 9, letter 27): in a place by the sea, there are more severe transgressions than in other places, because men and women, youths and also maidens, go to swim in the sea and come to sin. And only so as not to speak ill of Israel will I hold my tongue and not open my lips to the many evils done there, and the wealthy of the city and the teachers of Torah must give attention to this, that they should appoint guards who will circle there so that they do not allow any woman to go to the seashore; and even one who says that she is ill and must bathe in the sea for her health is not to be believed, and anyone who allows his wife to go to the seashore will ultimately become poor and die in the middle of his days.
Therefore, the hearts of fathers should be upon their children, to be strict concerning their sons who are youths, and likewise concerning their daughters, not to go to the seashore, for they will certainly come to several pitfalls and stumbling blocks. So wrote he. At first glance, there would be room to argue that one for whom bathing in the sea is a medical necessity is considered like a case where there is no other route, when he cannot find a beach free of mixing with women, for from the words of Rashbam it is evident that the requirement to close one’s eyes in such a case is only a matter of pious conduct. (Although the Meiri wrote that one must turn one’s eyes aside.) However, one can distinguish, for it was not permitted where there is no other route.
That is only when one is merely passing through, where it is possible not to look intentionally at the women standing while washing clothes, but to go and bathe in a mixed beach, where in every direction one turns there is a woman before him, a deceitful and guarded one, and it is impossible to refrain from looking and from coming to sinful thoughts during the time he remains there... Especially since there, when one walks his eyes will look straight ahead, and there is no concern that he will intentionally look at the shins of the women standing while washing clothes. But here the women are in their nakedness; can fire be placed in tow and not flare up (as they said in Sanhedrin 37a)? And it is also said: Can a man take fire into his lap and his garments not be burned? See also the great Rabbi Yitzchak HaKohen in the book Beit Kohenah (in the pamphlet Beit HaMidrash, page 2d). Furthermore, the Rambam (in chapter 21 of Hilchot Issurei Bi'ah, halacha 21) wrote simply that it is forbidden to look at women when they are standing while washing clothes. He did not distinguish between whether there is another route or not. (This was noted in the book Tzofnat Pa'neach there, and he cited what was said in Avodah Zarah 48b.)
So too, in the Tur and Shulchan Aruch, Even HaEzer (siman 21, se'if 1), they wrote according to the Rambam, and did not distinguish between whether there is another route or not. And in the book Az Nedaberu, volume 7 (siman 75), it was written that they hold that even where there is no other route, one must close his eyes. End of quote. And is it conceivable that he should go bathe in a mixed beach and keep his eyes closed the entire time? Therefore, there is no room at all for leniency in this matter.
See also the Midrash Rabbah, parashat Acharei Mot (section 23, siman 12): and the eye of the adulterer guards the twilight, Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish said that you should not say that only one who sins with his body is called an adulterer; rather, even one who sins with his eyes is called an adulterer, as it is said: and the eye of the adulterer guards the twilight. End of quote. And see Sanhedrin (75a) and the Rambam (chapter 5 of Hilchot Yesodei HaTorah, halacha 9).
And in the Beit Yosef, Yoreh De'ah (siman 157). End of quote. Therefore, one must refrain from bathing at a mixed beach where there is no separation between men and women, in any case, even for medical need; rather, he should find a place free of intermingling with women for the sake of his healing. And it is a mitzvah upon the leaders of the community, who fear Hashem and think upon His name, to strive to establish separate bathing places, to save many from sin, for it is a settled presumption that a person does not leave what is permitted and eat what is forbidden (Gittin 37b). And for those who rebuke, it is pleasing, and upon them will come a blessing of good. And the one who warns and the one who heeds will greatly increase their peace like a river.

