Women
What is the significance of a woman’s actions and observations during pregnancy and nursing?
Question
Hello,
Is there a reliable source for the idea that when a pregnant woman longs for a certain food and does not eat it, the baby will be born with a birthmark in the shape of that thing?
Also, what is the significance of bringing a pregnant woman what she longs for, or not bringing it to her, and what is the significance of her feelings, actions, and observations during pregnancy and nursing?
Thank you very much!
Answer
Hello,
1. To the best of my knowledge, there is no source for this.
2. It is stated in Tractate Yoma (folio 83a, and Rashi there) that if a pregnant woman smells the aroma of a cooked dish and longs for it, and does not eat, both she and the fetus are endangered.
3. It is stated in Tractate Ketubot (folio 60b and 61a, and Rashi there) that one who has relations while lying on the ground will have children with long necks; one who eats mustard will have children who are gluttons; one who is accustomed to eating small fish will have children whose eyes are constantly moving and darting; one who drinks beer will have children with dark complexion; one who eats meat and drinks wine will have healthy children; one who eats eggs will have children with large eyes; one who eats fish will have children of fine character; one who eats karpas (a kind of celery) will have children with radiance and beauty (according to Aruch, entry Ziv); one who eats coriander will have children with flesh; and one who eats etrog will have children with a pleasant smell. The Shitah Mekubetzet there (folio 60b) wrote that all of this refers to when she eats these foods while pregnant.
It should also be noted what is explained in Tractate Yoma (folio 75a, and Rashi there), that garlic and onions are harmful for pregnant women and nursing mothers. Likewise, in Sefer HaMiddot (entry Pregnancy, letter d), it says that pregnant and nursing women should not eat garlic and onions.
4. In Sefer Maavor Yabok (Maamar Siftei Tzaddik, chapter 5), it is written that it is proper for a woman to be careful during the days of her pregnancy not to go, and also not to look, at a place of transgression, and all the more so she should guard herself from any taint of sin, since the fetus in her womb sees and looks and knows much. Similarly, in Sefer Shevet Mussar (chapter 24), it is written that a woman should be especially careful during the days of her pregnancy not to enter places of impurity and places where there is a bad smell, because the child is formed according to what her eyes see. Rather, during her pregnancy she should sit in places of holiness and purity, in synagogues and study halls, and regularly see Torah scholars, pious people, and men of deed. She should hear words of Torah, for the words enter her ear and the child within her is sanctified.
Accordingly, there is a custom among many women not to visit the zoo during the days of their pregnancy, since it is explained in Sefer Yeshuot Chokhmah (siman 33, letter 11) that looking at impure animals brings a spirit of impurity upon a person (see also Sefer Kav HaYashar, chapter 2), and they were concerned that seeing impure animals would affect the child.
For this reason, many women are accustomed to immerse in a mikveh in the ninth month of pregnancy without a blessing, because this is a segulah for the child to be saved from all improper sights that his mother saw during the days of her pregnancy (see Sefer Netaei Gavriel, Laws of Niddah, part 3, chapter 56, section 19, which brings this segulah from Sefer Zechirah and Sefer Segulot Yisrael, and notes that it has spread in several communities, and that such is the custom in the holy city of Tiberias. By contrast, he brings from Sefer Bnei Beitecha in the name of the Satmar Rebbe, and from the Lubavitcher Rebbe in Sefer Shaarei Halacha uMinhag, that they had no tradition for this custom).
5. Regarding nursing - it is written in the holy Zohar (Parashat Vayikra, folio 19a) that a woman should not nurse after marital relations for the amount of time it takes to walk two mil, and if the baby is crying she may wait only the amount of time it takes to walk one mil. In the commentary Metok Medvash there, it is written that the reason for this halacha is because Lilit rules at the time of marital relations, and if she nurses the baby immediately afterward, she may, Heaven forfend, harm him and bring him to the point of convulsions.
This is also brought as halacha in Mishnah Berurah (siman 240, subparagraph 54) in the name of the Zohar, that after marital relations she should not nurse the child until after the amount of time of two mil. If the baby is crying, she should wait at least the amount of one mil.
Now, the measure of one mil is 18 minutes (and so wrote in this context Aruch HaShulchan, Orach Chaim, siman 240, section 18), and two mil is 36 minutes. According to this, ideally a woman should wait 36 minutes before nursing after marital relations. If the baby is crying, she may wait only 18 minutes.
However, in Sefer Taharat Yisrael, part 2 (siman 240, letter 88), it is written that ideally a woman should not nurse after marital relations for 36 minutes, and if the baby is crying she should wait 18 minutes. And if the baby is weak and crying, one may be lenient with half a mil - that is, 9 minutes.
It should be noted that only nursing is prohibited, but it is permitted to give the baby to drink from a bottle or to eat immediately after marital relations, and milk that was expressed before marital relations may likewise be given to the baby immediately (Responsa Shevet HaKehati, part 5, siman 48, letter 5).
6. In Sefer Zechirah (matters of segulot for a wet nurse), it is written that the wet nurse should not walk over anything repulsive, and all the more so over sewage. She should also be careful about anger, which stops the milk, etc.
7. In Kaf HaChaim, Yoreh Deah (siman 116, letter 148), he cites Zivchei Tzedek, that if she experiences fear and alarm from anything, she should not nurse the baby at that time until she calms down, and after the fear passes she should express a little milk from her breasts outside and only then nurse. And this has been tested and proven.
With blessings,
Hillel Meirs

