Faith
When Was the Zohar Written?
Question
As far as I know, the holy Zohar was written by Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and his son Elazar. I read a study that says the holy book was discovered in Spain in the 13th century and that it contains expressions attributed only to Spain, and that, according to them, it is clear that the geography of the Galilee in the book does not correspond to reality. Is there any truth to this article?
Yanon
Answer
Hello Yanon
On this subject, the answer must be divided into two parts: one intended for a believing public and one for a public that still does not believe, as well as those who simply wish to enrich their knowledge. For a believing person, there is no problem in the matter, since we know the sanctity of our sages and the greatness of their attainments, and especially in the time of the Ari and his disciples, the Ramchal, and the Gaon of Vilna, upon whom the holy spirit rested without any doubt and who were constantly dwelling in higher worlds, and if they accepted all the words of the Zohar without any concern, we are assured that the matter is verified and clear: it was written by the students of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai according to his revelation and teachings.
And now let us expand for those who are uncertain: the source in the words of the early authorities from the middle of the sixth millennium (about seven hundred years ago) for the Book of the Zohar exists, although in somewhat different names for the book, such as Midrash Yerushalmi or Midrash of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai explained in the Zohar and the like. The source for the Book of the Zohar under the name Zohar is attributed to its revelation by Rabbi Moshe de Leon, who lived around the date you mentioned in Spain; the leading researchers of the Zohar
G. Shalom and his student Y. Tishby held in all their works, except for the last of them, that the Book of the Zohar was certainly written by Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai (in any case, in his time), and later retracted this in their later writings without providing sufficient reason or refutations for all the proofs they had brought in their other books for the antiquity of the Zohar, and in his book he relied on a limited number of proofs (the source for further study is given at the end). Disputes about the origin of the Zohar took place among all the sages of Israel who lived at the time of its revelation, and this was a good thing that there was a dispute, because Judaism is critical and does not accept any claim or addition without the truth of the source first becoming clear, especially in such lofty matters. The dispute that took place in its time cannot serve as proof that the sages of that time were uncertain, because in the end the book was accepted into the tradition of Israel.
For every book that came out to argue against the Zohar regarding the nature of its origin and to deny its attribution to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, works were written to refute the proofs he brought. For example, in response to the book Bechinat HaDat, the book Matzref Chochmah was written to overturn all its claims; against the book Ari Nohem, the book Magen v’Tzinah was written to refute and resolve all its claims; and so on and so forth.
G. Shalom’s attempt to attribute the Zohar to Rabbi Moshe de Leon is highly puzzling, because according to him he wrote the Zohar in only six years, when the Zohar contains more than one thousand seven hundred pages, making him a man of extraordinary talent, while on the other hand he is said to have lacked mastery of language and translation; and when in the rest of his life he managed to write only a few other small books on the subject, this is most puzzling. I have not heard claims about the Galilee region; the main claims are about the language and the like. There is an extended article by Rabbi M. Kasher on the Daat website (Jewish Studies and Spirit Center) that refutes Shalom’s claims one by one and proves the opposite, bringing sources to show that the Zohar is very ancient. The reader can find what he seeks on the Daat website.

