Halachot and Customs
Does halacha give legitimacy to pedophilia?
Question
In the Babylonian Talmud, Niddah 45a, it is written that sexual relations with a girl under the age of 3 is not defined as sexual intercourse, and that their hymen is restored. It is also written in Mishneh Torah, Laws of Forbidden Relations, chapter 1, law 13, that sexual relations with a child under the age of 9 is exempt from punishment. Does halacha give legitimacy to pedophilia?
Answer
With Hashem's help
Hello and blessings,
In all the ancient Jewish communities, they would execute pedophiles, or exile them. Maimonides notes that for dangerous people a house of detention was built, which is the equivalent of prisons today. They would not allow rapists to roam free.
The violation of virginity has damages value in its own right, exactlyy like a person who injures his fellow's eye. This is a legal matter. The Gemara in this passage discusses the law of virginity, and not the punishment of the rapist. The rapist would be punished by the court even if he was not executed. The word exempt in the language of the Gemara does not mean exempt from punishment, but exempt from death.
Does the Torah not forbid pedophilia?
Leviticus (chapter 19): Do not profane your daughter by causing her to become a harlot, and the land will not become harlotry... A father who has relations with his daughter incurs the death penalty. A man who has sexual relations with a child is liable by Torah law to death (see above, the heading Prohibition of harlotry and licentiousness. As can be seen, apart from marriage between a man and a woman according to the law of Moses and Israel, there is no other kind of marriage in Judaism).
Leviticus (chapter 18): A man, do not draw near to any of your kin to uncover nakedness; I am Hashem - it is well known that the vast majority of acts of pedophilia are committed among family members, through incest. In Judaism, one who does so incurs the death penalty.
Our sages also said: (Kiddushin 41a): As Rav Yehuda said in the name of Rav, and some say Rabbi Elazar: It is forbidden for a man to betroth his daughter while she is a minor, until she grows up and says, In so-and-so I want. The woman chooses her husband on her own.
Maimonides ruled (Laws of Marriage, chapter 14, 10): If she says, I despise him and cannot be intimate with him of my own will, we force him to divorce her immediately, for she is not in captivity to be intimate with one who is hateful to her (that is, since she is not a captive to be taken by one who is hated by her).
Nevertheless, the Torah did not explicitly prohibit marriage between minors, and this is for a well-known historical reason: throughout history there were very difficult periods for the Jewish people, during which they were forced to marry off girls to boys, especially orphans, out of fear that gentiles would kidnap them, traffic them, or marry them against their will, which was fairly common in Islamic countries. I myself know grandparents who were married while still children for similar reasons. There was enormous danger for young Jewish girls of being kidnapped and married to gentiles who lusted after them, and a similar fear of trafficking and prostitution. Strangely, gentiles did not customarily kidnap or take married women. For this reason, there were periods when children were married at a very young age, so that the gentiles would not harm their children. When parents married off their children at a young age, they did so out of concern for their safety, and not any kind of pedophilia, Heaven forbid. Pedophilia was not accepted in any Jewish community, at any time (you are welcome to search the entire Shas, the Gemara, and the poskim for legitimation of such an act). Quite the opposite: in Judaism, there are known cases of pedophiles who were caught in the ancient Jewish community, and from what I read they were always executed, or expelled from the community.
Blessings,
Daniel Balas

