Prayer and Blessings
Is it permitted to put on tefillin before the blessing over the Torah?
Question
Hello, let us say that for reasons of time a person cannot both recite the blessing over the Torah and put on tefillin, and if he recites the blessing, the owner of the tefillin will leave and he will not be able to put them on that day. May he put on the tefillin? And if it is permitted to put them on, is it also permitted to say the verses that accompany the putting on before, during, and after?
Thank you very, very much
Answer
Hello,
It is possible to put on tefillin before the blessing over the Torah, especially when time is tight. However, it is proper to be stringent and not say the verses that are customarily said before putting on tefillin and after it.
Sources: In Mishnah Berurah (siman 47, seif katan 7), he cites Biur HaGra (there, seif 10), who writes that according to all opinions it is permitted to perform some act of a mitzvah before the blessing over the Torah, even though one certainly thinks about this law while doing so; nevertheless, it is permitted, since whenever one does not intend for study, no blessing is required. (However, see Biur Halacha, siman 588, seif 2, s.v. Shma, in the first reason, that one should not fulfill a mitzvah in an unclean place. Apparently, this contradicts his words in the above Mishnah Berurah. It can be distinguished.) It is likewise evident from the words of the Chida in the book Avodat HaKodesh (Kerech Gadol, siman 5, letters 30-31) that it is permitted to fulfill mitzvot and also to put on tefillin before the blessing over the Torah (and we cited his words below). And see that this is also proven in B'tzel HaChochmah, part 4 (siman 150, letter 8). Likewise, in Responsa Mahar"y Steif (siman 272), it is ruled that it is permitted to put on tefillin before the blessing over the Torah.
However, see B'kurei Yaakov (siman 644, seif katan 1), where he writes, and one recites the blessing over the Torah before taking the lulav. Apparently, from his words it is understood that one should not fulfill a mitzvah before the blessing over the Torah. Indeed, in the book Yafeh LaLev, part 1 (siman 25, letter 10), he concludes that one should not put on tefillin before the blessing over the Torah in light of the above-mentioned words of B'kurei Yaakov. And see further in Yafeh LaLev, part 2 (Last Section, siman 25, letter 1).
However, see the Admor, author of Imrei Emet, of blessed memory, in the book Michtavei Torah (siman 26), where he explains the words of B'kurei Yaakov according to the holy Zohar (Parashat Tzav), that with regard to a Torah scholar, a mitzvah is like Torah. According to this, for an ordinary person who is not a Torah scholar, there is no concern about putting on tefillin before the blessing over the Torah. Likewise, see something similar in the book Piskei Teshuvot, part 3 (siman 353, letter 3), where he writes to explain on the basis of what is written in the Tikkunei Zohar, that the mitzvot of Yom Tov are like Torah, and if so, one cannot infer from the four species to other mitzvot.
Or it may be explained as written in Responsa B'tzel HaChochmah (siman 150, letter 9), that perhaps the intent of B'kurei Yaakov is that one should recite the blessing over the Torah before taking the four species because of the verses Vehi Noam, etc., which are said during the performance of the mitzvah, and there the B'kurei Yaakov is following the ruling of the Arizal, that one should recite the blessing over the lulav before walking to the synagogue in the sukkah. In truth, according to the Arizal, one says Vehi Noam, etc., when fulfilling a mitzvah. This is also explained in the book Chazon Ovadia, Sukkot (page 372). See further in Responsa Eretz Tzvi (siman 16), Responsa Lev Avraham (siman 7), Responsa Revavot Ephraim, part 1 (siman 39, letter 1) and part 2 (siman 80, letter 5, and siman 170, letter 24), Responsa Shevet HaKehati, part 3 (siman 340, letter 1), and the book Moadim U'Zmanim, part 8 (siman 116).
In any case, as a practical ruling, we hold that as a matter of strict law it is permitted to fulfill mitzvot before the blessing over the Torah, and see also in Responsa B'tzel HaChochmah (there) that he concluded that it is permitted to fulfill a mitzvah even before one has recited the blessing over the Torah. However, pious and meticulous people who are careful to recite the blessing over the Torah before fulfilling mitzvot connected to Yom Tov, and likewise Torah scholars who are careful to recite the blessing over the Torah before fulfilling any mitzvah, may they be blessed. This was also agreed to in Responsa Be'er Sarim, part 3 (siman 45, letter 4). See further there in part 6 (siman 12, letter 2). And see further in B'tzel HaChochmah there, that in a time of need even those who are meticulous may fulfill a mitzvah and only afterward recite the blessing over the Torah. Apply this to our case.
And regarding what was written, that it is proper to be stringent, etc., see Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim (siman 46, seif 9), the Rema there, and Mishnah Berurah (seif katan 28). Likewise, see in our case the Chida in his book Avodat HaKodesh (Kerech Gadol, siman 5, letter 30), who writes that those accustomed to say the verse Vehi Noam before every mitzvah should not say it before the blessing over the Torah. And there (seif 31) he further writes that those accustomed to say the verse Va'erasteich li be'emunah, etc., after donning tefillin should not say it if they have not recited the blessing over the Torah.
With blessing,
Hillel Meirs

