Faith
Whom should be honored first for sandak honors, the paternal grandfather or the maternal grandfather?
Question
I am, with Hashem's help, expecting a son.
From the standpoint of honoring parents, whom should I honor with the sandak honor, the child's maternal grandfather or paternal grandfather?
Both sides are religious and God-fearing.
I would like a halachic answer so that we can tell the parents that this is a choice based on halacha and not because of greater honor, etc....
Thank you very much.
Answer
Greetings,
The paternal grandfather should be honored first with the sandak honor.
Sources: According to Lequet Yosher, part Yoreh Deah (page 52). And similarly wrote the late Hagaon R. Chaim Palagi in Responsa Chaim Biyad (siman 75), that such was the custom in his city, Izmir: when a man was blessed with his first son, the first sandak honor was given to the side of the father of the child, and for the second son he would give the sandak honor to the child's mother side. And similarly in the book Hilchot Olam, part 8 (page 164), that the custom is for the father-in-law to serve as sandak for his first grandson, and the maternal grandfather serves as sandak for the second grandson. And see further in Responsa Shevet HaKehi, part 4 (siman 234), that if there is no side reason requiring one of them to be honored, it seems that his father comes first by virtue of the positive commandment of honoring one's father, which is from the Torah.
With a good and auspicious hour,
Hillel Meirs

