Jewish Law

Honoring Your Parents: When Does Halacha Require You to Stand?

Honoring parents goes beyond words. Learn the halachot of standing for a father or mother and how this mitzvah applies in everyday situations.

(Photo: Shutterstock)(Photo: Shutterstock)
aA

Honoring our parents is one of the Torah’s most fundamental mitzvot, but it extends far beyond speaking respectfully or helping them when they need us. Halacha teaches that even something as simple as standing when a parent enters the room can be an important expression of kibbud av va’em. When must a child stand, how long should they remain standing, and what happens during prayer or Torah study? Here are some of the key halachot to know.

The Obligation to Stand

When a father or mother enters a room, a son is obligated to stand in their honor. This obligation applies not only at home, but in other settings as well.

How Many Times a Day?

A person should stand for their father and mother every time they enter, even if it happens a hundred times a day. However, according to some Ashkenazic customs, one is required to stand only twice a day.

A Love for the Mitzvah, Not a Burden

If a son is already standing and knows that his parents are about to enter, it is proper for him to sit down briefly so that he can fulfill the mitzvah of standing when they enter.

If a son is sitting and sees his parents approaching, he may not close his eyes in order to avoid seeing them and thereby avoid the obligation to stand. Regarding such matters of the heart, the Torah says, “And you shall fear your God, I am Hashem.” Only Hashem knows whether a person truly did not see or merely pretended not to.

If a son stands in honor of his parents but also needs to go somewhere, it is best for him to sit down first before leaving. In this way, it is clear that he stood specifically to honor his parents rather than simply because he was getting up to leave.

Parents, however, should not deliberately walk in front of their children simply to make them stand. If they can take another route that does not require their children to repeatedly rise, it is appropriate to do so. This is also considered a segulah for long life.

During Prayer and Torah Study

Even if a son is reciting Shema when his father enters, he must stand in his honor. The same applies while reciting Birkat HaMazon or other blessings.

If a son is sitting and studying Torah when his parents enter the room, he must stand to honor them, but he should not interrupt his learning. He should simply stand and continue studying. If his parents enter and leave frequently and standing each time makes it difficult for him to study, he may ask them to forgive him for not standing.

From What Distance Must You Stand?

A son who sees his parents approaching must stand in their honor, even from a considerable distance. Therefore, if he is in a very large hall and sees his father entering from far away, he must stand even if his father does not see him. He should remain standing until his father is out of sight.

Even though it may not be obvious from such a distance that he is standing specifically for his father, honoring parents in this way is connected to the mitzvah of awe and therefore does not depend on whether the gesture is noticeable.

A blind son who hears his parents entering the room must also stand. Similarly, if the father is blind and cannot see his son standing, or suffers from memory loss and does not recognize him, the son must still stand fully upright when his father enters.

How Should You Stand?

The obligation is to stand fully upright on one’s feet, not merely to lift oneself slightly from the chair.

Ideally, a son should stand without leaning against a wall or another object. However, according to halacha, he may lean slightly, provided that he would remain standing if the support were removed.

Rabbi Tzedakah Chutzin, zt"l, a student of the great Ben Ish Chai, zt"l, came to the Holy Land in 1926 and settled in Jerusalem, where he established the Shamash Tzedakah synagogue on Chagai Street. He was a great Torah scholar who believed that learning must lead to action.

Once, while studying with a prominent Jerusalem scholar about 20 years younger than himself, Rabbi Tzedakah asked whether he was careful to stand fully upright when his mother entered, as halacha requires.

The scholar admitted that he would rise slightly but did not stand completely upright.

Rabbi Tzedakah immediately closed the book in front of him and said, “We have finished learning for today. It is impossible to learn and not apply! When you come and tell me that you now stand fully upright for your mother, we will resume our learning.”

The following day, the scholar returned and told his rabbi that he had corrected his behavior and now stood fully upright for his mother. Only then did Rabbi Tzedakah resume their learning together.

How Long Must You Remain Standing?

A son should remain standing until his father or mother sits down or gives him permission to sit.

If the father enters and remains standing in one place because he is occupied with something, the son may sit, since that spot has effectively become the father’s place. However, if the father is merely pausing before continuing on his way, the son should remain standing until his father sits down.

If a son is sitting in the kitchen eating while his mother is cooking and constantly moving from one place to another, he does not appear to be required to stand the entire time. Since she is occupied with cooking, the kitchen can be considered her established space. Nevertheless, whenever possible, it is best to ask one’s parents to forgive the obligation to stand in such circumstances.

Honoring a Father in the Synagogue

If a son’s father goes to the bimah to serve as the prayer leader, the son should stand from the moment his father leaves his seat until he reaches the bimah. When the prayer concludes and the father returns to his seat, the son should stand again until his father sits down. He does not need to remain standing while his father is at the bimah, since that has become his established place.

When a father is called to the Torah, his son should stand in his honor and remain standing throughout the reading until his father returns to his seat. If the father remains at the bimah after his aliyah to wait for the next person to finish, the son does not need to remain standing during that time. He should stand again when his father returns to his seat. If the father receives Maftir, the son need only stand during the Torah reading and does not have to remain standing for the haftarah or its blessings.

When a son finishes his own aliyah to the Torah, he should approach his father, kiss his hand, and receive his blessing. This, too, is part of honoring Hashem, Who commanded us to honor our parents. (Ben Ish Chai, Parashat Vayikra)

At the same time, one should be careful not to kiss a friend, child, or parent on the face inside the synagogue. This helps instill in our hearts that no love compares to our love for the Creator. A father who usually kisses his sons after prayers or following their Torah reading should preferably do so outside the synagogue.

At Family Celebrations

At a family celebration, if a father is walking among the guests and serving wine, his son does not need to stand each time his father passes by. Since the father wants his guests to remain seated and enjoy the meal, the son should respect that wish. However, when the father personally pours wine for his son, the son should stand rather than remain seated while his father serves him.

Although our sages teach that a groom during the first seven days of marriage is like a king, he is still obligated to stand in honor of his father and mother.

During Mourning and Tisha B’Av

A mourner sitting shiva is not obligated to stand when his father enters because our sages did not impose this obligation on someone preoccupied with grief. Nevertheless, it is good to make an effort to rise slightly in his father’s honor.

However, if a son is sitting on the ground on Tisha B’Av and his father enters, he must stand in his honor.

When Parents Forgive Their Honor

If parents forgive the honor due to them, the son is no longer obligated to stand, although it is still proper for him to rise slightly. If he chooses to stand fully, he fulfills a mitzvah.

If other people are present and do not know that the parents have waived this honor, however, the son should stand so that his actions are not misunderstood.

If parents specifically object to their son standing because it causes them distress, he should respect their wishes. As the principle states, a person’s wishes are part of their honor. At the same time, he may gently explain that standing for them is a Torah mitzvah and a precious opportunity that carries great reward.

A son should not ordinarily ask his parents to waive their honor simply because he does not want to stand. An exception may be made when there is a legitimate reason, such as when he is writing Torah teachings and his parents enter frequently, making repeated interruptions difficult.

Even a Great Scholar Must Honor His Parents

Even if a son is a great Torah scholar and his father is uneducated, he must stand for and honor his father without diminishing his respect in any way. On the contrary, a wise son should be even more eager to honor his parents.

If a father asks his scholarly son, in front of others, to perform a task that the son would not normally do publicly because it is beneath his dignity, he is not obligated to do so. However, if it is something he would do for himself, he must also do it for his father. In private, he should fulfill his father’s requests even when the task is not in keeping with his usual dignity.

A son who merits writing a Torah book for the benefit of the public should acknowledge and praise his parents for raising him and helping him reach that achievement. Even if they did not raise him in the ways of Torah and mitzvot, he should still express gratitude, recognizing that he owes his very ability to achieve to them.

When a Son Teaches Torah to His Father

If a son teaches Torah to his father and thereby becomes his father’s teacher, both are required to stand for one another. However, it is advisable for the son to waive the honor due to him as a teacher so that his father does not need to stand fully for him.

In such a case, the son is not obligated to serve his father, just as the father is not obligated to serve his son in his capacity as his Torah teacher. Nevertheless, the son may waive the honor due to him and serve his father.

When Standing Disrupts Torah Study

If a father and son attend the same Torah class and the son standing when his father enters disrupts the lesson, it is preferable for the father to forgive his son and allow him to remain seated.

Similarly, if the son’s standing causes everyone else in the class to stand as well and this causes the father discomfort, the son should ask his father to forgive the obligation.

However, if the son remaining seated could lead others to become less careful about honoring their own parents, he should stand for his father even if his father has waived the honor. In that situation, the example he sets for others also matters.


Tags:honoring parentsJewish lawHalachaTorah lessonsTorah wisdomJewish faith

Articles you might missed