Personality Development

If Everything Is Predetermined, Why Make an Effort?

If Hashem controls the outcome, why do our actions matter? Discover how Judaism balances free will, divine providence, and hishtadlut—the responsibility to make an effort while trusting in Hashem.

aA

There's an old joke about a religious man who prayed every day to win the lottery. After years of unanswered prayers, he finally looked toward heaven in frustration and cried, "Why won't You help me?" A heavenly voice replied, "I want to help you. But first, buy a lottery ticket!"

It's a humorous story, but it raises a serious question: If everything is determined by Hashem, why should we bother making an effort? There are two common approaches to this question, but Judaism offers a third perspective that balances personal responsibility with faith in divine providence.

Two Extremes: Everything Is Predetermined or Everything Depends on You

The first approach assumes that everything has already been decided. Whatever is meant to happen will happen, regardless of our actions. If that's the case, why work hard, pursue opportunities, or make plans? The problem with this outlook is that it separates effort from results and undermines personal responsibility. Taken to its extreme, it encourages passivity, as though our role is simply to sit back and wait for miracles. Yet the Torah presents a different expectation. Already in the Garden of Eden, Adam was placed there "to work it and to guard it" (Genesis 2:15). Human beings were created to participate actively in the world, not merely observe it.

The opposite extreme insists that everything depends entirely on us. Work hard enough, make the right decisions, and success is guaranteed. If something goes wrong, the assumption is that we simply didn't try hard enough. Although this perspective can be motivating, it also carries a heavy emotional burden. When success is treated as a direct measure of personal effort, setbacks may lead to anxiety, frustration, and guilt. It can also encourage people to justify questionable behavior in their determination to achieve results.

Judaism offers a more balanced understanding: We are responsible for our choices and efforts, but we do not control the ultimate outcome.

Free Will and Divine Providence

Jewish tradition teaches that many aspects of our lives are influenced by divine decree, including our circumstances, opportunities, and the events we encounter. Some matters are determined before birth, while others are subject to divine judgment, particularly on Rosh Hashanah.

At the same time, our Sages establish a fundamental principle: "Everything is in the hands of Heaven except the fear of Heaven" (Berachot 33b). Although much of what happens to us lies beyond our control, we remain responsible for our moral and spiritual choices. Whether we act honestly or dishonestly, fulfill our obligations or neglect them, and choose what is right over what is convenient belongs to the realm of free will. We cannot guarantee success, but we can choose how to conduct ourselves while pursuing it.

Why Does Hashem Expect Us to Make an Effort?

In Jewish thought, hishtadlut—the practical effort we invest in achieving our goals—is not necessarily the ultimate source of our success. Rather, it is the natural means through which the blessings Hashem provides can reach us. If our livelihood and circumstances are ultimately determined by Heaven, why are we still expected to work, plan, and take initiative? There are four important reasons.

1. Effort Is Part of Our Responsibility

Following Adam's sin, the Torah declares, "By the sweat of your brow you shall eat bread" (Genesis 3:19). Work is part of the human experience, and we are expected to take practical steps to support ourselves and fulfill our responsibilities rather than depend on supernatural intervention.

2. Our Efforts Test Our Faith

It's relatively easy to declare that our livelihood comes from Hashem. The real test comes when an attractive business opportunity requires compromising our values. Will we remain honest when dishonesty appears more profitable? Will we observe halacha even when doing so seems inconvenient?

The same principle applies to everyday religious observance, from keeping kosher to following the laws governing modesty and clothing. Hashem does not ask us to live like angels, detached from material reality. He expects us to engage with the world while remaining faithful to His commandments.

3. Effort Helps Us Appreciate What We Receive

Things that require patience and perseverance often become especially meaningful. Consider someone who spends years searching for a suitable spouse before finally finding the right match. Having experienced the challenges of the process, that person may develop a deeper appreciation for the relationship. Effort can help us recognize the value of what we have been given rather than take it for granted.

4. Hashem Governs the World Through Nature

Jewish teachings sometimes connect the Hebrew word olam, meaning "world," with he'elem, meaning "concealment." The idea is that Hashem's presence is not always openly apparent. Instead, divine providence operates through the ordinary processes of nature, allowing human beings to exercise free will. If every prayer were immediately answered through an unmistakable miracle, the nature of faith and human choice would be fundamentally different.

Our responsibility is therefore to act within the natural world while recognizing that the ultimate outcome remains in Hashem's hands. There are exceptional individuals whose extraordinary level of trust in Hashem allows them to rely more heavily on prayer and spiritual devotion. However, this represents an unusually elevated spiritual level, not the ordinary expectation for most people.

Understanding the Relationship Between Potential and Effort

A helpful analogy can be drawn from the relationship between natural ability and personal development. Psychologists have long studied how genetics and environmental influences contribute to intelligence and other human abilities. Both inherited characteristics and life experiences play important roles in shaping development.

Consider two hypothetical children. One is born with considerable intellectual potential but grows up in an environment offering few opportunities for learning or encouragement. Another begins with more modest natural advantages but receives strong educational support, stimulation, and guidance. The second child may ultimately achieve more, not because natural abilities are irrelevant, but because effort and opportunity help determine how those abilities develop.

The comparison is not exact—human intelligence cannot be reduced to a fixed genetic ceiling—but it illustrates an important principle: What we are given and what we do with it are two different things.

A similar idea can help us understand the relationship between divine blessing and human effort. Jewish teachings describe the blessings available to a person as influenced by both heavenly judgment and individual conduct. Our choices do not give us complete control over the results, but they can affect our spiritual capacity to receive and make use of what Hashem provides.

Good deeds, mitzvot, and spiritual growth can be understood as widening the channel through which blessing flows, while harmful choices may obstruct it. Imagine an employer who establishes clear criteria for promotions and salary increases. Employees do not have the authority to award themselves a raise, but their conduct and performance may influence the employer's decision. Similarly, although the ultimate judgment belongs to Hashem, our actions are far from meaningless.

Take Action, but Leave the Outcome to Hashem

The practical lesson is straightforward. If we need a job, we should send out our résumé and pursue opportunities. If we're looking for a spouse, we should make appropriate efforts to find one. If we're ill, we should seek medical treatment. Prayer and trust in Hashem do not eliminate the need for responsible action.

At the same time, our efforts should not become a source of excessive anxiety or the mistaken belief that everything depends entirely on us. We are expected to make a reasonable effort, act ethically, and fulfill our responsibilities. Beyond that, we must recognize that the results are not ours to determine.

This understanding can bring both motivation and peace of mind. We have a meaningful role to play, but we are not required to control every aspect of our future. Furthermore, Jewish teachings emphasize that spiritual growth, mitzvot, and good deeds can positively influence the way divine blessing is bestowed upon us. Although we cannot dictate Hashem's decisions, our choices matter deeply.

Ultimately, the Jewish approach is neither passive resignation nor the exhausting belief that success depends entirely on personal effort. We must do our part while trusting Hashem to determine the outcome. And sometimes, that means remembering to buy the lottery ticket before praying to win.

Tags:Divine ProvidencefaithlivelihoodJewish Thoughtfree choicehuman effort

More on This Topic

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube