Parashat Chayei Sarah

What You Admire Reveals Who You Are: A Powerful Jewish Lesson

What reveals a person's true character? Discover how a surprising lesson from Ishmael's repentance, the teachings of Rabbeinu Yonah, and inspiring stories of great Torah scholars show that what we admire shapes who we become.

(Photo: Flash 90)(Photo: Flash 90)
aA

We are often warned not to judge people by appearances. But perhaps even a deeper acquaintance is not enough to reveal a person's true character. Surprisingly, even someone's actions, although undoubtedly important, may not provide a complete picture of who they really are.

There is, however, another way to understand a person's inner character: by examining what they admire, whom they respect, and the qualities they consider worthy of praise. This profound insight emerges from an unexpected detail in the Torah's account of Abraham's burial.

What Ishmael's Respect for Isaac Reveals About Repentance

At the end of Parashat Chayei Sarah, the Torah describes Abraham's burial: "And Isaac and Ishmael, his sons, buried him" (Genesis 25:9). Rashi, citing our Sages, explains that the order of the names is significant. Ishmael allowed Isaac to precede him, demonstrating that he had repented.

This raises a puzzling question. According to the Sages, Ishmael had displayed serious wrongdoing from an early age. Rashi explains that the Torah's description of Ishmael as metzachek alludes to idolatry, forbidden relationships, and bloodshed. How, then, could one seemingly minor act of allowing his younger brother to go first, serve as evidence of genuine repentance? Could this gesture really indicate a fundamental transformation in his character?

The answer lies in a remarkable teaching of Rabbeinu Yonah in Shaarei Teshuvah (3:148). Quoting Proverbs (27:21), "As the refining pot is for silver and the furnace for gold, so is a man according to his praise," Rabbeinu Yonah explains that a person's true character can be discerned from what he chooses to praise.

Someone who admires righteous deeds, Torah scholars, and people of integrity reveals that goodness has taken root within him. Even if he still struggles with wrongdoing, his appreciation for righteousness demonstrates that his deepest values are directed toward what is good. Conversely, someone who praises immoral conduct or glorifies wicked people reveals something troubling about his own moral outlook.

Rabbeinu Yonah develops this idea further in his commentary on Pirkei Avot (4:6). He explains that the way a person speaks about righteous individuals provides an indication of his character. Someone who consistently recognizes their virtues demonstrates an affinity for goodness, while one who disparages the righteous and justifies the behavior of the wicked reveals a different set of values.

A person's deepest character is reflected not only in what they do, but in what they consider admirable. People sometimes stumble despite genuinely wanting to do what is right. Their actions may fall short of their ideals, but the very fact that they admire goodness indicates an inner connection to it.

This explains the significance of Ishmael's behavior at Abraham's burial. As the older brother, he would ordinarily have taken precedence over Isaac. By voluntarily stepping aside and honoring Isaac's position, Ishmael demonstrated that his priorities had changed. He now recognized and respected Isaac's spiritual standing. It was not merely a gesture of courtesy. It revealed a transformation in what Ishmael valued—and therefore provided evidence of repentance at a deeper level.

The Values We Admire Shape Our Homes

The Talmud teaches in Shabbat 23b that someone who honors Torah scholars will merit sons-in-law who are Torah scholars. The principle extends beyond a promise of reward. A person who genuinely admires Torah learning creates an atmosphere in which Torah scholarship is respected and valued. Even if he is not personally an accomplished scholar, his appreciation for Torah influences the character of his home and the aspirations of his family.

The opposite can also occur. Someone may spend considerable time studying Torah while privately reserving his greatest admiration for wealth, prestige, or worldly success. His stated priorities and his actual values may not be entirely aligned.

A striking story illustrates the power of genuine respect for Torah scholars. The renowned Rabbi Elchanan Wasserman, who was murdered during the Holocaust, once visited a wealthy supporter of his yeshiva. Having traveled through the muddy roads of a Russian winter, Rabbi Wasserman arrived with mud covering his shoes. Rather than soil the carpets, he entered the home through a side entrance.

When the wealthy homeowner realized what had happened, he was deeply distressed. "Rabbi, what will become of my daughters' education?" he cried. "They'll think that our carpets are more important than honoring the Torah!"

His reaction revealed what truly mattered to him. He was not concerned about the condition of his expensive furnishings but about the message his daughters might absorb concerning respect for Torah scholarship.

The account relates that he subsequently merited distinguished Torah scholars as sons-in-law, including Rabbi Moshe Mordechai Epstein, who later headed the Slabodka Yeshiva, and Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, who became head of the Kletsk Yeshiva and later taught at the Etz Chaim Yeshiva in Jerusalem.

Children learn not only from what their parents tell them to value, but from what they see their parents genuinely admire.

Respect for Judaism Beyond Religious Observance

This distinction can also help explain differences in how people relate to Jewish tradition, even when their levels of religious observance are similar.

In Israeli society, for example, many Jews who identify with the political right maintain a strong emotional connection to Jewish tradition. Some may not observe every mitzvah, yet they hold Torah scholars and religious leaders in profound esteem. Figures such as Rabbi Ovadia Yosef represent sources of spiritual authority and inspiration for them. That respect can reflect a deep connection to Jewish values, even when personal observance is incomplete.

Political affiliation, however, is not a reliable measure of a person's religious character. Attitudes toward Judaism vary considerably across Israeli society, including among people who identify with the political left. The broader lesson is not about assigning spiritual value to political groups, but about recognizing the significance of what an individual genuinely honors and respects.

A person's inner values may be revealed by the ideals they admire, even when they have not yet succeeded in fully living up to them.

How Stories of Goodness Can Change Us

Rabbeinu Yonah's interpretation of "a man according to his praise" offers more than a method of understanding character. It also suggests a way to cultivate goodness within ourselves. What we admire does not merely reflect who we are; it can also influence who we become.

When we speak about noble actions, appreciate acts of kindness, and read about people who demonstrate extraordinary sensitivity, we strengthen our own connection to those qualities.

Rabbi Shlomo Hoffman, a respected educator and psychologist, addressed this idea in Conversations With Rabbi Shlomo Hoffman. He described one of the foundations of successful education as awakening the desire to do good.

One way to accomplish this, he explained, is through storytelling. Rather than relying exclusively on instruction or criticism, an educator can inspire moral growth by introducing examples of admirable behavior. A story of exceptional kindness can awaken the desire to become kinder. An account of self-sacrifice can strengthen our appreciation for devotion. When we encounter genuine greatness of character, we may find ourselves wanting to embody those qualities.

Two remarkable stories illustrate this principle.

The Rabbi Who Wouldn't Interrupt a Young Woman's Song

Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, author of Even HaAzel, was once observed behaving rather strangely outside his home. He climbed the stairs toward his apartment, paused near the door, and then descended again. A short while later, he repeated the same routine. He continued going up and down the stairs several times before finally entering.

Someone who witnessed this unusual behavior asked what was troubling him. Rabbi Meltzer offered a simple explanation. He had heard the young woman cleaning his home singing to herself as she worked. He knew that the moment he entered, she would become self-conscious and stop singing.

The young woman, he explained, had a difficult life. Her singing provided a few moments of happiness, and he could not bring himself to interrupt that small pleasure.

A great Torah scholar, occupied with weighty responsibilities, was sensitive enough to recognize the importance of a few moments of joy in another person's day. His concern was not merely to avoid causing harm, but to preserve someone else's happiness.

Rabbi Shach's Concern for Women Who Had Nowhere Else to Pray

Another powerful example comes from Rabbi Elazar Menachem Man Shach, the renowned head of the Ponevezh Yeshiva, who regarded his uncle, Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, as an important role model in matters of character.

Approximately forty-five years ago, the Ponevezh Yeshiva experienced severe overcrowding during the High Holy Days. So many people wanted to attend the services that there was insufficient space for the yeshiva's own students and married scholars. A proposal was raised to allocate most of the women's section to male worshippers, particularly younger students. A smaller portion would remain available for the wives of faculty members and other women closely connected to the yeshiva.

The organizers approached Rabbi Shach for approval. Rather than answer immediately, he asked them to return in an hour so that he could consider the matter carefully. When they came back, his response was unequivocal: "Promise me that you will not do this under any circumstances—and that you will never raise the idea again."

The organizers were astonished. They had expected him to support a practical solution that would enable more yeshiva students to pray in the building. Why was he so firmly opposed?

Rabbi Shach explained that he had considered which women would actually lose their places. The wives of the rabbis and prominent members of the yeshiva community would likely retain their seats. Many wives of younger married scholars were occupied with small children and could not leave home for lengthy services. Who, then, would be displaced?

Women who had not been blessed with children and older unmarried women who were still waiting to find their matches. These were precisely the women who might already be carrying profound emotional pain. "How could we hurt them?" Rabbi Shach asked.

To him, the question was not simply one of maximizing seating capacity. It was about recognizing the feelings of individuals who might otherwise be overlooked. Even as a leader responsible for one of the world's most prominent yeshivot, Rabbi Shach refused to allow organizational considerations to overshadow compassion for vulnerable individuals. 

Perhaps it was precisely this sensitivity that made him worthy of leading so many others.

Becoming What We Admire

These stories reveal a profound dimension of spiritual growth. Greatness is not measured solely by intellectual achievement, outward accomplishment, or public recognition. It is also expressed through the quiet decisions that reveal what a person genuinely values.

Rabbi Meltzer's concern for a young woman's fleeting happiness and Rabbi Shach's determination to protect the dignity of unmarried women demonstrate a sensitivity that cannot be measured by conventional standards of success. Their actions also offer something more than inspiration. They invite us to examine our own priorities.

What qualities impress us most? Whose achievements do we celebrate? Do we admire wealth and status, or are we moved by integrity, compassion, and devotion to Torah?

Rabbeinu Yonah teaches that our answers reveal something essential about our inner character. Rabbi Hoffman's educational approach suggests that those answers can also be changed and strengthened.

By surrounding ourselves with stories of kindness, moral courage, and genuine spiritual greatness, we can awaken those same qualities within ourselves. May we merit not only to recognize goodness when we encounter it, but also to develop the desire and sensitivity to bring more of it into the world.

Tags:character traitsTeshuvaheducationRabbi ShachTalmudsensitivityTorah scholarshonoring TorahRabbi Isser Zalman Meltzerrespect

More on This Topic

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube