Jewish Law
How to Pray: Lessons From Choni HaMe'agel
What does Jewish law teach about personal prayers, when to ask Hashem for help, and prayers considered futile?
- Yosef Yaavetz
- | Updated

In Jerusalem, more than 2,000 years ago, two Hasmonean brothers, Hyrcanus and Aristobulus, were fighting for control of the kingdom. Aristobulus and the priests supporting him had barricaded themselves on the Temple Mount, while Hyrcanus, aided by an Arab army, laid siege to the area.
During the conflict, Hyrcanus's soldiers discovered a righteous man hiding in a secluded location. They dragged him into their camp and demanded that he pray for the defeat of those under siege. The man was Choni HaMe'agel, the celebrated sage whose prayers had once brought an end to a devastating drought during the time of Shimon ben Shetach. Knowing his extraordinary reputation, Hyrcanus's supporters hoped that his prayers would secure them a swift victory.
But Choni refused to pray as they demanded. According to Josephus in Antiquities of the Jews (Book 14, Chapter 2), Choni declared that both sides belonged to Hashem and prayed that He would not heed the curses they directed against one another. Enraged by his refusal to take their side, Hyrcanus's supporters killed him.
This account raises a question, since the Talmud describes Choni's death differently, relating that he died after awakening from a 70-year sleep and finding himself unable to reconnect with his contemporaries. The Maharsha addresses this apparent contradiction, suggesting that Choni had disappeared because of his prolonged sleep and was mistakenly believed to have been killed. Another explanation holds that there were two sages named Choni HaMe'agel, a grandfather and grandson.
Beyond these differing accounts, Choni's story introduces a fundamental question: How should we approach Hashem in prayer, and what makes a request appropriate?
Choni HaMe'agel and the Power of Prayer
The Mishnah (Ta'anit 3:8) recounts that most of the month of Adar had passed without rain. Desperate for relief, the sages approached Choni and asked him to pray. Choni prayed, but no rain fell.
He then drew a circle on the ground, stood inside it, and declared: "Master of the Universe, Your children have turned to me because I am like a member of Your household before You. I swear by Your great Name that I will not move from here until You have mercy on Your children."
Rain began to fall, but only in scattered drops. Choni responded that this was not what he had requested; the people needed enough rain to fill their cisterns, ditches, and caves. The rain then became torrential, prompting Choni to pray once more, explaining that he had asked for beneficial rain rather than destructive rainfall. Finally, a steady, nourishing rain began to fall, continuing until the people of Jerusalem were forced to seek higher ground on the Temple Mount.
Choni had refined his request three times: first because the rain was insufficient, then because it was excessive, and finally because what the people truly needed was balanced, beneficial rainfall. When they subsequently asked him to pray for the rain to stop, Choni responded that he had received a tradition that one does not pray for an excess of goodness. Nevertheless, he asked them to bring him a thanksgiving offering. The Mishnah similarly teaches that public prayers are offered in response to various calamities, with the exception of excessive rainfall.
Afterward, Shimon ben Shetach sent Choni a remarkable message: "Were you anyone other than Choni, I would decree excommunication upon you. But what can I do? You act before the Almighty like a child who makes demands of his father, and his father fulfills his wishes."
Shimon ben Shetach concluded with the verse, "Let your father and mother rejoice, and let she who bore you be glad" (Proverbs 23:25). Choni's extraordinary closeness to Hashem allowed him to pray with the familiarity of a child addressing a loving father. Yet Shimon ben Shetach made clear that this manner of prayer was not an example for everyone to imitate. Prayer is an intimate relationship with Hashem, but it must also be approached with humility and an awareness of the proper boundaries.
When and How Should We Make Personal Requests?
The Talmud (Avodah Zarah 7b) records a disagreement about the appropriate time to make personal requests during prayer. Rabbi Eliezer maintains that they should be offered before the formal prayer, Rabbi Yehoshua says afterward, and the Sages teach that they belong within the prayer itself, specifically in the blessing of Shomea Tefillah.
The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 119:1) follows the opinion of the Sages and explains that a person may include personal requests in this blessing. These may concern the individual or others, as well as present and future needs, such as livelihood, family health, or children growing to become G-d-fearing individuals.
Requests directly related to a particular blessing may also be included in that blessing. For example, someone praying for a sick person may add a personal request during Refa'einu, the blessing for healing. However, personal needs are not requested during the first three or final three blessings of the Amidah, which are reserved for praise and thanksgiving (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 112:1).
The Rambam describes the basic structure of prayer in Hilchot Tefillah (1:2): A person begins by praising Hashem, continues by presenting personal needs through prayer and supplication, and concludes by expressing thanks.
Notably, there is no requirement to limit our requests to spiritual concerns. The Talmud (Niddah 70b) discusses how a person may become wealthy, advising honest business dealings together with prayer to the One who possesses all wealth. Prayer and practical effort are therefore not contradictory. We are expected to act responsibly while recognizing that our success ultimately depends on Hashem.
The guidelines for prayer change on Shabbat. Our Sages generally prohibited making ordinary personal requests on this day, which is why the weekday Amidah's thirteen middle blessings are replaced by a single blessing focused on the sanctity of Shabbat.
Shabbat is intended to be a day of rest and spiritual tranquility, free from the worries that accompany our everyday needs. An important exception applies when someone is in danger. In such circumstances, prayers and urgent appeals may be offered even on Shabbat.
When Is a Prayer Considered Futile?
Not every request is considered appropriate. The Mishnah (Berachot 9:3) introduces the concept of tefillat shav, a futile prayer, describing requests concerning matters that have already been determined.
For example, someone who hears cries coming from a city while approaching it and prays that the disturbance does not involve his family is offering a futile prayer, since whatever happened has already occurred. Similarly, the Mishnah considers it futile for a man whose wife is pregnant to pray that the unborn child will be a boy, since the child's sex is understood to have already been determined.
The Talmud (Berachot 60a) explains that such a request may be made during the first 40 days of pregnancy, but afterward it is considered a futile prayer. The Jerusalem Talmud takes a more lenient position, treating the request as futile only once the woman has entered labor. The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 230:1) follows the Babylonian Talmud.
This raises an intriguing question concerning Leah, the wife of Yaakov Avinu. According to the Midrash, Leah knew that Yaakov was destined to father twelve tribes. She had already given birth to six sons, while the two maidservants had borne four more. If Leah's next child were a boy, her sister Rachel would have the opportunity to give birth to only one son, fewer than either maidservant.
Leah therefore prayed for Rachel's sake, and according to the Midrash, the child she was carrying became a daughter—Dinah. How could Leah's prayer have changed something that was seemingly already determined? One explanation is that Leah possessed an extraordinary spiritual stature and prophetic insight. Her experience represented an exceptional miracle and cannot be taken as a general model for ordinary prayer.
Another example appears in the Talmud (Bava Metzia 42a), which teaches that someone who prays for blessing upon grain only after measuring it has offered a futile prayer. Blessing is associated with that which remains concealed from the eye, rather than with quantities that have already been measured or counted. Accordingly, someone wishing to pray for blessing upon stored grain should do so before measuring it.
These teachings emphasize the importance of understanding what we are asking for and whether the circumstances still allow for the requested outcome.
Is a Futile Prayer Actually Forbidden?
The Mishnah describes such requests as tefillat shav, or futile prayers, but does not explicitly state that they are prohibited. This raises a halachic question: Is such a prayer forbidden, or is it simply ineffective?
In his work Chefetz Hashem, the author maintains that offering a futile prayer is prohibited. The question therefore extends beyond whether the prayer will accomplish anything and concerns the proper way to address Hashem.
For those praying with a congregation, there is also a practical consideration. It is preferable to add extended personal requests after reciting Yihyu l'ratzon toward the end of the Amidah, so that one can respond to Kaddish and Kedushah when necessary.
Prayer Requires Both Faith and Discernment
The teachings of Choni HaMe'agel and our Sages reveal that prayer is not simply a matter of asking Hashem for whatever we want, whenever we want it. It involves understanding the nature of our requests, the appropriate time to express them, and the proper way to approach the Almighty.
Choni's remarkable prayers demonstrated the extraordinary closeness a righteous person can attain with Hashem. Yet the response of Shimon ben Shetach reminds us that such intimacy must be accompanied by reverence and humility.
The halachic guidelines surrounding personal requests, Shabbat prayers, and futile prayers reinforce the same principle: Prayer is not an attempt to dictate reality to Hashem, but an opportunity to turn to Him with sincerity, responsibility, and trust.





