Words of Torah

What Is Meant for You Cannot Be Taken Away: A Powerful Lesson From the Talmud

Discover the Jewish teaching that another person's success does not diminish your own opportunities, and how faith in Hashem can help us overcome comparison, jealousy, and disappointment

aA

“No person can touch what has been prepared for another, and no kingdom can encroach upon the time allotted to another, even by a hair’s breadth.” (Yoma 38b)

The Talmud teaches a profound principle of Jewish faith: What Hashem has destined for one person cannot be taken away by another. This teaching, found in a discussion about those who held positions in the Beit Hamikdash, reminds us that every individual has a unique place and portion in the world.

In this context, the Talmud quotes Ben Azzai: “By your name they will call you, in your place they will seat you, and from what is yours they will give you. No person can touch what has been prepared for another, and no kingdom can encroach upon the time allotted to another, even by a hair’s breadth.” Rashi explains that whatever a person receives is not a gift taken from someone else's portion, but rather the sustenance that Heaven has allotted specifically to them.

This teaching speaks to an experience most of us know all too well. Imagine applying for a position you desperately want, only to discover that someone else has been hired. You recognize that the successful candidate is talented and qualified, yet a difficult question lingers: Why them and not me? Similar feelings can surface when a friend achieves financial success, someone we know purchases a home, or those around us seem to be moving forward while we are still waiting for our own opportunities. Even when we genuinely wish others well, their achievements can bring our own disappointments into sharper focus.

The Talmud offers a different perspective: Someone else's success does not diminish what is meant for us. Life is not a competition in which every gain for one person represents a loss for another. Each of us has a portion designated by Hashem, even when we cannot yet see how or when it will unfold.

This does not mean we should sit back and wait for things to happen. Jewish faith places great importance on hishtadlut—making a sincere and responsible effort. Someone seeking employment must continue pursuing opportunities, just as someone hoping to build a successful business must invest the necessary time and work. Faith does not replace effort, but it changes our relationship with the outcome. We do what is within our power while recognizing that the results are ultimately in Hashem's hands.

This understanding can free us from the exhausting tendency to measure our progress against the achievements of others. Instead of interpreting someone else's good fortune as evidence of what we lack, we can recognize that their success belongs to their journey, just as our opportunities belong to ours. It becomes possible to celebrate another person's happiness wholeheartedly, without feeling that it has come at our expense.

When we internalize the belief that what is meant for us cannot be taken by someone else, we can pursue our goals with determination, accept disappointments with greater perspective, and find genuine happiness in the blessings others receive. There is room for someone else's success without diminishing the possibilities that await us.

Tags:TalmudfaithJewish wisdomenvysuccesstrust in Hashemparnassah

More on This Topic

Articles you might missed

Shorts

The latest short videos from Hidabroot on YouTube