Behind the News
The Applause in Venice: When Anti-Israel Activism Meets Antisemitism
The acclaim for the documentary Collateral Damage raises troubling questions about anti-Israel sentiment in Europe, the motivations of Israeli left-wing activists, and the limits of acceptance within the global progressive movement
- Yehuda Aizikowitz
- | Updated

Approximately two and a half years ago, at the beginning of the Swords of Iron War, Israeli left-wing activists Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor published an investigation claiming that only a small minority of Palestinians killed in Gaza were Hamas terrorists. Despite serious questions about the report's factual basis, Britain's The Guardian embraced its findings. The allegations offered a particularly powerful means of portraying Israel as responsible for the indiscriminate killing of civilians, not least because they came from Israelis themselves.
The activists have since produced Collateral Damage (Nezek Agavi), a feature-length documentary that takes those allegations further. Rather than simply accusing Israeli forces of recklessly killing Palestinians, the film suggests that such killings are deliberate and systematic.
The documentary relies heavily on anonymous testimonies, raising questions about the ability to independently verify its claims. Without identifying details, precise locations, or evidence that can be subjected to meaningful scrutiny, viewers are asked to accept accounts delivered by obscured figures. Even the identities of those speaking remain difficult to establish. Yet these uncertainties appear to have done little to dampen the enthusiasm of audiences already predisposed to accept the film's conclusions.
If the earlier investigation was warmly received in European left-wing circles, the documentary generated an even more enthusiastic response. Following its screening at the Venice Film Festival, the audience reportedly applauded for approximately 25 minutes, and the film received a jury prize. The reception recalled the acclaim given the previous year to another film accusing Israeli forces of deliberately killing a Palestinian girl.
When Condemnation Becomes a Source of Moral Satisfaction
The applause in Venice represented something more troubling than appreciation for a documentary. It seemed to reflect a collective sense of relief: an opportunity to condemn Jews while feeling morally justified in doing so.
The disturbing historical parallel is the antisemitism of medieval Europe, when fabricated blood libels accused Jews of murdering Christian children. Those accusations allowed hostility toward Jews to masquerade as moral outrage. Today, a similar danger arises when allegations against Israel are embraced without sufficient scrutiny and opposition to Israeli policies becomes entangled with hostility toward Jews themselves.
The result is a troubling inversion of morality. Condemning Israel becomes not merely acceptable but a demonstration of virtue, while questioning the allegations risks being interpreted as indifference to Palestinian suffering. The stronger the condemnation, the greater the perceived moral standing of those expressing it.
The Growing Divide Between Israeli and Global Progressives
Why would Israeli activists participate in producing material that could contribute to international efforts to isolate their own country?
Part of the explanation may lie in the widening ideological divide between Israel's radical left and the global progressive movement. In recent years, segments of the international far left have aligned themselves with Islamist causes and adopted increasingly hostile attitudes toward Israel. For Israeli activists who have personally experienced the consequences of Islamist terrorism, reconciling those positions with their own reality presents a particular challenge.
This creates an uncomfortable dilemma for Israeli progressives who regard Europe's intellectual and political elite as their natural ideological community. While they identify strongly with those circles, they may find themselves regarded with suspicion simply because they are Israeli. Their nationality becomes associated with a political identity that their international counterparts reject, leaving them struggling for acceptance within the very movement to which they feel they belong.
In this environment, producing a documentary that presents Israel in an exceptionally negative light can serve as a declaration of ideological loyalty. Such a film may strengthen international campaigns for military and economic sanctions against Israel, while simultaneously allowing its Israeli creators to demonstrate that they belong on what they perceive as the morally correct side of the conflict.
It also offers a way to resolve the cognitive dissonance created by belonging to a nation increasingly condemned by one's chosen ideological community. By publicly distancing themselves from Israel and embracing the prevailing narrative, activists may hope to regain the approval and recognition of the global progressive movement.
The Limits of Acceptance
The reaction to the Venice screening exposed a revealing contradiction. Although the Israeli filmmakers received enthusiastic applause at the festival, they also faced hostile criticism on social media. Some commentators objected to Jewish Israelis receiving awards and recognition while Palestinians continued to suffer in Gaza.
The backlash suggests that ideological agreement does not necessarily guarantee acceptance. Even when Israeli activists adopt positions closely aligned with anti-Israel movements, their Jewish identity can remain a source of resentment.
There is a profound irony in this dynamic. Israeli voices may be welcomed when they reinforce accusations against Israel, yet the individuals behind those voices can still find themselves rejected by the very people whose approval they seek.
Ultimately, the applause in Venice raises a question that extends far beyond a single documentary. What happens when political condemnation becomes a measure of moral virtue, and when belonging to an ideological movement requires ever more emphatic denunciations of one's own society?
For Israeli activists seeking acceptance within international progressive circles, the answer may prove uncomfortable: even the harshest criticism of Israel may not be enough to overcome the prejudices of those who applaud it.
World NewsBarack Obama Faces Criticism Over Remarks on Israel and Jewish History
World NewsReport: Harvard Awards Fellowships to Four Anti-Israel Activists
Behind the NewsKraft Super Bowl Ad Triggers Jewish Debate Over How to Fight Antisemitism
Behind the NewsRemembering Israel’s Fallen Heroes Through Tefillin
